Mossberg Pumps (500's)- Do ALL their pumps rattle? [Archive] - Glock Talk

PDA

View Full Version : Mossberg Pumps (500's)- Do ALL their pumps rattle?


ScrappyDoo
01-23-2010, 19:36
LSS, came close to buying a Mossberg 500 today at Dick's because this forum seems to RAVE about Mossberg..

The young man in the gun cage had a very good point and showed and proved it.... ALL the Mossberg pump shotguns they had rattled/shaked ...the "handle" part you would hold onto to "pump" ... *ALL* would shake, rattle, and roll when handled... he said that's why he bought a Remington 870. I mean, I was ready to buy one, the price was right and the selection was plentiful, but he dutifully ( and correctly, it did seem) that ALL the Mossberg's rattled/shaked whereas all the Remington's were solid as a rock/stable.

Now the reason I post this is because I don't know ***** about ***** so I'm hoping for an explanation , hopefully it has nothing to do with anything.

(What I'm REALLY hoping for is someone to show me the autoloading Mossberg with the stock, pistol grip, etc. and how much/where to buy, cause THAT Thing seems to be the bomb...)...

Otherwise I'm thinking next weekend I'm going with the Remington 11-87... please make me smart here. I wanted a Remington, knowing little, this board made me want a Mossberg, but today I was swayed back. What do I want to do?

And what is the deal with the rattle/shaking of the Mossberg?

k594
01-23-2010, 20:49
i have a mossberg 500 it rattles as well, id go with the rem 870 ... just my 2 cents

Puppy
01-23-2010, 21:04
It is really a non-issue.

I own Mossberg 500 & 590A1 & Remington 870, if I had to choose one for an emergency, life or death sort of situation I wouldn't hesitate to reach for either brand, however I do tend to prefer my Mossbergs a little more due to their better ergonomics.

ScrappyDoo
01-23-2010, 21:07
i have a mossberg 500 it rattles as well, id go with the rem 870 ... just my 2 cents

Can I interpret that as you'd rather have a Rem yourself?

k594
01-23-2010, 21:11
Can I interpret that as you'd rather have a Rem yourself?

i own a moss 500 as well as a remington 870.

the 870 is my fav of the two

CTfam
01-23-2010, 21:47
I own a Mossberg 500a "rattle trap". Yeah it's sort of a sloppy pig but it is a great gun for the money. If you want a better fit and finish you may want to go with the 870.

I will pick up an 870 one day. I could care less about the rattle it's just the controls on the Mossberg don't jive well with the Spec Ops stock I put on it. The most important thing is the placement of the controls.

Maybe check out a Benelli Super Nova Tactical? They look hella sweet.

GTSteve03
01-24-2010, 11:37
I have a 590A1 and it doesn't rattle. Maybe the 500s have a little looser tolerances?

mixflip
01-24-2010, 12:18
Lots of guns build for reliability vs accuracy will rattle due to slightly looser tolerances. The looser tolerances provide easier action especially in dirty environments. That being said...shotguns are not known for finesse. They are devastating and brutal meat tenderizers so a little rattle is fine with me.

Whats the big deal about a rattle if you are gonna hear a loud and intimidating "shuck - shuck" anyways?

Jake514
01-24-2010, 12:26
27 years ago I paid $100 for a new Mossberg 500. It has thousands of rounds through it and has always rattled, but never quit or jammed. Not a big deal IMHO.

Blitzer
01-24-2010, 12:54
Lots of guns build for reliability vs accuracy will rattle due to slightly looser tolerances. The looser tolerances provide easier action especially in dirty environments. That being said...shotguns are not known for finesse. They are devastating and brutal meat tenderizers so a little rattle is fine with me.

Whats the big deal about a rattle if you are gonna hear a loud and intimidating "shuck - shuck" anyways?

The parts that rattle have little to do with the Mossberg 500's accuracy? :dunno:

ranger56528
01-24-2010, 13:39
I bought Both my 20 and 12 500's in late 70's and there still going strong,never let me down,bought them both at the Holiday Gas Station in town and they have been a rattlin ever since..

das9mm26
01-24-2010, 14:04
Having owned both the Moss 500A and the Rem 870P, I can safely say
I would trust my life - and the lives of my loved ones - as readily with the 500 as the 870.....and for an MSRP of a couple hundred $$ LESS.....
My opinion....Buy a Moss 500A....use the savings to stock up on #4 or 00 buckshot.....!:cool:

nnmnu1
01-24-2010, 15:49
I like how everyone says its a great gun but cant explain why it rattles.

mixflip
01-24-2010, 17:48
They rattle because the 2 action bars have slightly more space that they sit in. Well, at least mine do anyway?

Ebb27
01-24-2010, 21:20
I like how everyone says its a great gun but cant explain why it rattles.



Uh yes they did.


The Mossberg is built to looser tolerances.




Lots of guns build for reliability vs accuracy will rattle due to slightly looser tolerances. The looser tolerances provide easier action especially in dirty environments. That being said...shotguns are not known for finesse. They are devastating and brutal meat tenderizers so a little rattle is fine with me.

Whats the big deal about a rattle if you are gonna hear a loud and intimidating "shuck - shuck" anyways?

MrMurphy
01-24-2010, 21:29
It's a moving part. Most pump guns rattle, or eventually do.

I've owned 870s, a 500 and a Nova SP. All rattled a bit in various places.

I've shot and carried other 870s, 590s, etc.

I prefer the 870 over all of them, but i'll use any of them cheerfully whether they rattle or not.

CAcop
01-25-2010, 00:02
I had a 500 once and I do have a 590A1. The 500 rattled a bit, nothing to worry about, the 590A1 does not rettle much at all. In fact the 590A1 is a little tight if you ask me.

KaosV
01-25-2010, 01:56
Like many others, I have a Mossberg 500 (also rattles) and a Remington 870 (doesn't rattle). Both are very good shotguns, but I prefer the 870. However, if I had to grab one in a split second, I'd be happy with either. It's all really personal preference.

sambeaux2249
01-25-2010, 02:33
*shrugs* I think all my shotguns rattle to some degree if you shake them hard enough...

My Benelli Nova and Maverick 88 sure do. The Chinese knockoffs of the 870's seem to rattle the least. My Mossberg 590 is about the same, little or no rattle. My 870 with wood stocks rattles more than the ones with synthetic stocks...

If I remember right, the Remingtons have some spring tension on the action bars, where the Mossbergs do not?

Regardless, the noise from the forend rattling is less noticeable than my sling swivels rattling and FAR less noisy than actually operating the shotgun.

Sam

vafish
01-25-2010, 06:08
I have 3 Mossberg 500's and 1 Remington 870.

The 2 newer Mossberg's have very little rattle to the fore end. The older one the fore end rattles around the mag tube quite a bit. I bought it used and have no idea how many rounds have been fired through it. It was fairly abused looking when I got it. After some sand blasting and Duracoat it looks great.

The 870 rattles a little bit as well. I've had it since the mid 1980's and it has been shot quite a bit.

If the fore end rattle bothers you then get the 870, but it really has no effect whatsoever on the function of the 500. The 870 will eventually start to rattle a bit too on the fore end.

The rattle on the 500 is mostly due to the design of the action bars and the amount of space between the fore end tube and the magazine tube. The action bars on the 500 are separate pieces pinned to the fore end tube and can move independently. This helps eliminate binding in the action of the fore end is twisted. The Remington 870 action bars are welded to the fore end tube and do not move.

gnepig
01-25-2010, 10:11
I have 3 Mossberg 500's and 1 Remington 870.

The 2 newer Mossberg's have very little rattle to the fore end. The older one the fore end rattles around the mag tube quite a bit. I bought it used and have no idea how many rounds have been fired through it. It was fairly abused looking when I got it. After some sand blasting and Duracoat it looks great.

The 870 rattles a little bit as well. I've had it since the mid 1980's and it has been shot quite a bit.

If the fore end rattle bothers you then get the 870, but it really has no effect whatsoever on the function of the 500. The 870 will eventually start to rattle a bit too on the fore end.

The rattle on the 500 is mostly due to the design of the action bars and the amount of space between the fore end tube and the magazine tube. The action bars on the 500 are separate pieces pinned to the fore end tube and can move independently. This helps eliminate binding in the action of the fore end is twisted. The Remington 870 action bars are welded to the fore end tube and do not move.


I own 2 Mossberg 500s and the rattle has never bothered me either, it kinda amplifies the "shuck - shuck" sound we like.
Sounds like your sales person is some kinda whiney mall ninja.

Thrillhouse700
01-25-2010, 10:44
I have noticed a good rattle in my mossy as well, I don't care much it still goes boom every single time.

From handling a few diff mossberg 500's I can tell you that some rattle more than others and here is why...........


The cheaper mossberg 500, sold at big 5 and other various sporting goods stores are build cheaper. The action tube on these is that of a maverick 88, the action bars are built into the slide, if you look at the fore end of the slide there is no retaining nut. This causes it to have a little more slop, but it still works well.

The higher end mossbergs have actual stand alone action slide tubes, and then a slide that mounts to it via retaining nut. These are slightly tighter and the action bars are part of the tube (one piece) so have less movement.

The Dicks sporting goods kid prob assumes all Mossbergs rattle because the company he works for only buys and re sells the cheaper versions of the mossberg. Not saying these are bad guns i own one and I love it.

The good part is if you get a cheaper version of the gun you can replace the slide action tube if you really want to.

USMC03Grunt
01-25-2010, 11:47
Some Mossbergs rattle, some don't and others fall somewhere in between with a slight rattle. Like most everybody said, it's designed with looser tolerances and IMHO, that's not always a bad thing as it is space for dirt and debris to go rather than stop everything from working completely. Next, loose tolerances in a rifle can be a bad thing since a sloppy rifle produces sloppy groups (although they tend to work longer with more crud in the action) such as an AK-47 for example and if accuracy is your game, you are going to want much tighter tolerances. However, what are we discussing? It's a freakin' shotgun and "accuracy" isn't a term generally applied to a weapon designed to fire buck and shot so I really see it as a non-issue.

ScrappyDoo
01-25-2010, 12:32
I found out today that apparently I can't get the Mossberg autoloader "that everybody wants, the one with the pistol grip and the 8 round mag capacity..." apparently illegal in NJ. The gunshop man said I could get a DIFFERENT Mossberg autoloader, "but not the one with the pistol grip and stock that everyone keeps asking for"....

So the plot thickens. I know I can get an 11-87 cause i've seen them for sale, and I've seen, as I said, Mossberg and Remington pumps. Freaking NJ.

CTfam
01-25-2010, 13:08
I found out today that apparently I can't get the Mossberg autoloader "that everybody wants, the one with the pistol grip and the 8 round mag capacity..." apparently illegal in NJ. The gunshop man said I could get a DIFFERENT Mossberg autoloader, "but not the one with the pistol grip and stock that everyone keeps asking for"....

So the plot thickens. I know I can get an 11-87 cause i've seen them for sale, and I've seen, as I said, Mossberg and Remington pumps. Freaking NJ.

Yeah that sucks. Honestly, you don't want a Mossberg with pistol grip. You can't reach the controls right. Check out the 930spx with standard stock. Looks bad ass. Don't know much about the 11-87. I'm sure it's sweet too.

Jmzzl
01-25-2010, 14:35
Mine wasn't all that bad from the factory, but I added a Mako tactical pump this past October, and it wobbles pretty bad. It may be a pet peeve to some, but I don't really mind it all that much.

fragout
01-25-2010, 16:56
Pumps rattle, but Mossbergs rattle the most. I used many 590's in the Army, great shotgun. But it's heavy and rattles more than a 870 for sure.
No big deal really, didn't rattle enough on patrol to matter. A 590 will last untill the end of the earth, but the just don't feel as tight as an 870.

1smoothredneck
01-27-2010, 13:04
LOTS of rounds through 500s in my time, and I can't recall a single problem.
Rem 870 is fine, but I prefer the 500 for ergonomics, and value to boot.
Be safe

tebklr
02-02-2010, 19:04
My Mossberg 500s rattle like two skeletons gettin' it on in a metal trash can. :wow: They also run flawlessly. Never a hiccup.

My 870 does not rattle.

I like them all.

Southpaw69
02-03-2010, 00:04
My 500 rattles a bit, i just went and shook it...i never noticed before.

So, for shaking use the 870 is the clear winner.

For shooting, they are both fine. I got the 500 because i'm a lefty and the safety is in a better place for me.

TxGun
02-03-2010, 00:22
Non-issue. I have 20 or so pump guns of all kinds. Most rattle somewhat. The Mossberg might rattle a bit more than most, but it's as reliable as any of them. Worry about something else because this isn't worth the time.