Glock 26 vs. Ruger SR9c vs. S&W M&P9c [Archive] - Glock Talk

PDA

View Full Version : Glock 26 vs. Ruger SR9c vs. S&W M&P9c


chpullen
02-25-2010, 18:27
I am looking to buy a sub-compact (for lack of a better term) 9mm for IWB carry and have so far narrowed my choice down to these three pistols. I own a full size version of each, so I'm familiar with and like each platform. Each has its pros. Here is how I size them up so far:

Glock 26-smallest of the three in every dimension. Glock reliability. Accessories abound. Not the best-looking of the bunch, but I like the way Glocks look. Again, there's that Glock reliability.

Ruger SR9c-largest in every dimension. Questions about barrel peening and lousy trigger due to full size SR9 issues on some guns. My full size has been fine but the trigger does need work. The biggest positives are a great-feeling grip and this, in my opinion, is the best looking of the three.

S&W M&P9c-this one splits the difference between the Glock and the Ruger size-wise in virtually every dimension. Plus, it's a Smith and I've always had VERY good luck with all my Smith and Wessons. Plus their customer service is second to none. The changeable backstraps are a plus. This is the capacity champ, w/ 12 rounds standard. Pretty cool looking too.

The prices on these here are pretty equal. I like them all, but I'm really interested in everyone else's experiences with any of these or just your thoughts. Let me know what you think.

Cole125
02-25-2010, 18:49
You really cannot go wrong with either of the three. If it were my money I would get the Glock 26. Easy to find parts, holsters, mags, ect. Just a no BS gun. As you said Glock reliability. Reliability is the most important thing in a life saving carry gun.

The SR9c is about the size of a G19. Very thin grip, probably the most comfortable of the three.

btolliverjr
02-25-2010, 18:53
I have an M&P9c and absolutely love it. I chose it over the G26 by a slight margin. Very equal in terms of reliability, quality, etc. I also have a G30SF and love it as well, but it is a .45 not a 9mm and you seem to be looking for a 9mm.

MarccraM
02-25-2010, 19:02
I have the mp9c and I can tell you that I would recommend the glock. I think the sw is amazing and yes the capacty is great.. I'm just so weight/size sensitive personally that the slightly lighter smaller platform of the glock clinches it for me..

Bottom line.. I bought a g27 for edc, but I'm keeping the mp9c cause its just great all around for the range or if the 27 is for some reason unavailable.

garageman
02-25-2010, 19:19
A friend and I went to the range a while back and rented a S&W9c and brought her XD9c and my G26. We both found the XD and G26 equally accurate and easy to shoot and we also both did NOT like the trigger pull of the Smith at all.

I went another time (same range and I think same rental S&W9c) with another friend from work who was looking for her first gun. I brought my Glocks and we rented the S&W again. We had numerous jamming issues with the Smith but none with the Glocks. That being said, I do not know the history of the rental and would think it had many thousands of rounds through it so it could be this gun's issues. I have heard of many with the Smith having no issues at all.

I would recommend shooting all of these if possible as you would find the one that fits you best. I have no experience at all with the Ruger.

chpullen
02-25-2010, 19:30
Good info here. Please keep it coming.

mlk18
02-25-2010, 19:55
I have never touched an SR9C, but I am aware that their trigger system is different from the SR9. Reportedly it's better. But the peening issue has scared me away from the Ruger SR-series as well.

I owned a Glock 26 for awhile, just could not fall in love with it. Too fat and chunky for a concealed carry gun (IMO). I much prefer the Glock 19 and feel that the G19 conceals better and gives you 5 more rounds of ammo. Lots of people love their G26's and I suppose it always comes down to how it feels in your hand and rides on your hip.

I fired a friends M&P9C this past fall and really like it. Smaller than the G19 but bigger than the G26. While it supposedly as wide as the Glock it feels much slimmer. I have added the M&P9C to my short list of future gun purchases.

I suppose you post here and people will steer you toward the Glock, while your identical post on the S&W Forum will result in everyone voting for the Smith. I always recommend in the end that you put each one in your hand as ergonomics are a major factor and is very subjective.

Good luck.

den888
02-25-2010, 22:16
This is a Glock forum and I own a G26 and love it...

-gunut-
02-25-2010, 22:26
The only one I have is the G26. I have to say that I really like it.

It shoots like a full size, conceals with ease (not to mention extremely comfortable), allows me to use 10rnd, 15rnd, or 17rnd as a backup (you can always go +2 extension or a 33rnd but I am talking standard), accurate, and reliable.

I don't have any experiance with the others, so I cannot comment. I do like my G26 thought and I am sure you will enjoy it also. I would head to a gun shop and handle all 3.

http://i29.photobucket.com/albums/c294/-GuNuT-/Glock/IMG_2301.jpg

http://i29.photobucket.com/albums/c294/-GuNuT-/Glock/IMG_2302.jpg

dnuggett
02-25-2010, 22:30
I was looking for another carry gun to rotate with my Sig 229 when the weather gets warmer so I ranked these three as well as 6 others in the "9mm carry class" against each other based in my criteria for a carry gun. The M&P9c ranked just ahead of the G26 which ranked just ahead of the SR9c. My M&P9c will rotate as a carry gun with my Sig 229 as clothing/weather dictates.

The Glock holds 12 as well. The SR9c will hold 15 with the 15 round mag that comes with it. And the grip is adjustable to match.

I believe the M&P is the lighter of the bunch.

CBennett
02-26-2010, 04:37
Glock should be reliable but is thick and has a thick grip some people dont like...you also cant normally get your pinky on it some care some dont. i cant use Glocks they dont fit my hand right. but they may yours..I pass on all Glocks except the Glock 36 which fits my hands but I cant afford at the time.

Ruger SR9c the peening...well I have no idea ive not seen it on mine..the trigger is COMPLETELY DIFFERENT from the SR9..in fact its closer to Glock like in its "weight" and almost 2 pounds lighter than the SR9's trigger and thats out of the box not broken in at all...I have heard that the new SR9's will be coming out with this new improved trigger all the SR9c's have its slimmer in grip and slide than the Glock..it actually fits in my hand just fine even without the grip extension I can get my pinky(barley) on the grip. I like the 17 round reload that was a pretty cool idea so while the regular mag is a 10 rounder you get a nice 17 rounder that fits too and fits flush with the grip extension.

S&W M&P Compact..again very nice and a bit more miles on it than the Ruger..for me it would go M&P/Rugersr9c, Glock...and the Ruger drops to #2 only because of its "newness" as its not got the miles and "proven reliability" like Glock and even M&P now that its been out a few years.

If the prices are honestly equal you have poor shops(price wise) because the Ruger should be at least $100 less.
and actually as far as prices go Ruger should easily beat the other 2 and by at least $100 the Ruger is around $400-415 out the door the others are at least(at least where I am) $100+ more.

CBennett
02-26-2010, 04:43
A friend and I went to the range a while back and rented a S&W9c and brought her XD9c and my G26. We both found the XD and G26 equally accurate and easy to shoot and we also both did NOT like the trigger pull of the Smith at all.

I went another time (same range and I think same rental S&W9c) with another friend from work who was looking for her first gun. I brought my Glocks and we rented the S&W again. We had numerous jamming issues with the Smith but none with the Glocks. That being said, I do not know the history of the rental and would think it had many thousands of rounds through it so it could be this gun's issues. I have heard of many with the Smith having no issues at all.

I would recommend shooting all of these if possible as you would find the one that fits you best. I have no experience at all with the Ruger.


yup id chalk it up to not cleaning because I have near 400 rounds through the Ruger so far and never had a single jam. it does not like WWB ammo...thats the only thing ive found out but since I can get American Eagle CHEAPER than WWB thats a moot issue. From the writeups on other forums ive not seen much of a jamming issue either..only thing I saw was when new they have a very stiff slide thats hard to get to lock back(by hand) even though it locks back fine after every mag is empty...also one biggie to remember the slide stop is just that a slide stop its NOT a slide release..so new at least its near impossible to use it as a release..thats fine with me and they tell you that in the manual and say its a slide STOP and recommend sling shot method and thats what they taught in the Police academy anyways so in no way bothers me.

CBennett
02-26-2010, 04:44
I was looking for another carry gun to rotate with my Sig 229 when the weather gets warmer so I ranked these three as well as 6 others in the "9mm carry class" against each other based in my criteria for a carry gun. The M&P9c ranked just ahead of the G26 which ranked just ahead of the SR9c. My M&P9c will rotate as a carry gun with my Sig 229 as clothing/weather dictates.

The Glock holds 12 as well. The SR9c will hold 15 with the 15 round mag that comes with it. And the grip is adjustable to match.

I believe the M&P is the lighter of the bunch.

actually its a 17 round mag so you get a bonus 2 :)

CBennett
02-26-2010, 04:46
This is a Glock forum and I own a G26 and love it...

but make sure you handle one first and shoot it ..I thought I was gonna be a Glock fan also and was strongly disapointed in their big fat wide grips..so much so that I ended up trading it in on the SR9c..that said its a great gun, reliable, will go bang every time(as will the M&P and Ruger) but check out the grips first and dont think you will get "used to them" if they dont feel right..thats what I thought..4 years later I had a hell of a time selling or trading that Glock at $375.

Billet
02-26-2010, 07:33
I chose the M&P 9c over the G26 and HKP2000SK, mostly because it was more ergonomic. The 9c comes standard with both flat and extended baseplates, and I found it just as easy to conceal as the G26 when the flat baseplate was used. Mine has only 1,000 rounds through it, but its been flawless. Its a great shooter, and I was shocked by how accurate it is.

Willieboy
02-26-2010, 09:54
I would opt for the G26 in a New York minute. I like Ruger's revolvers but the auto you speak of has had many problems from what I've read. Regarding S&W, I know over the years their quality control has been spotty, and in recent years they have changed manufacturing processes on their revolvers to reduce cost. I fear they may be making similar moves with their autos.

chpullen
02-27-2010, 08:20
Thanks for the responses. I went ahead, after handling all three, and got the Glock 26. Happy so far. Any recommendations for a thin, affordable Kydex holster ?

mastrbloata
02-27-2010, 08:52
Thanks for the responses. I went ahead, after handling all three, and got the Glock 26. Happy so far. Any recommendations for a thin, affordable Kydex holster ?

M-Tac? Affordable? Well, that may be another matter.

Cole125
02-27-2010, 11:18
Thanks for the responses. I went ahead, after handling all three, and got the Glock 26. Happy so far. Any recommendations for a thin, affordable Kydex holster ?

Congrats! :supergrin: The tradition around here when someone claims to get a new gun... :needspics:

gunreviewonmyspace
02-27-2010, 11:24
I can not speak to the other two with great detail, but I love the G26. I own an assortment of pistols including several glocks, and previously owned a 26. I am now scheming my way back into a 26 because nothing I have seems to fit that nitch of small summer carry gun, easy to shoot, ultra reliable, and good capacity. I like the 26 of all compact 9s because it is so comfortable to shoot well. I regret trading my 26 for a XD9 sub.

garand4life
02-27-2010, 12:27
I love my M&P9c! I have night sights that to me make all the difference for carry. I didn't like the safety lever on the SR9c when I held it. It just became distracting. My M&P does not have the safety I might add. This thing is a tank and because it is becoming such a popular gun the aftermarket is exploding with options.

carbuncle
02-27-2010, 15:31
As I do more research into the M&P series, I have to ask: do I still get to come to Glock Talk if I don't own a Glock?

On topic, I posted my opinion in the same thread on the S&W forums but to recap for folks here: we went to my new favorite LGS today to see if my wife liked the fit of the G26 and also took a look at the M&PC due largely to a great salesman. Afterward the wife said, "the Glock felt like I was holding a plastic pistol, the other one (the M&PC) felt like a real gun." I couldn't agree more.

rfd339
02-27-2010, 16:38
actually its a 17 round mag so you get a bonus 2 :)

Checked out a sr9c Friday and it felt pretty good but I think getting a 17rd mag with a 10rd mag kinda sucks. You have to go buy a $43 10rd mag so you can carry. I understand the 17 rounder can used for range but defeats the purpose in a way. My 2 pennies.:dunno:

Hendricks433
02-27-2010, 17:35
M-Tac? Affordable? Well, that may be another matter.

a good holster is very important and not cheap.

Dont go cheap on the holster.

codyzx7
02-27-2010, 18:00
Thanks for the responses. I went ahead, after handling all three, and got the Glock 26. Happy so far. Any recommendations for a thin, affordable Kydex holster ?

I just received an RMLowrider today. I can not begin to tell you how much I like it. Super comfortable. Highly recommended!!

texanredraider
02-27-2010, 18:07
I don't know if this helps your decision, but I got an email today from S&W about the start of another rebate program for the M&P line - $50 or 2 magazines, Feb. 27 until May 31.

Willieboy
02-27-2010, 18:11
I've been using Comp-Tac for many years and have never been disappointed. In fact, I have another on order as I write this.

CBennett
02-27-2010, 18:38
Checked out a sr9c Friday and it felt pretty good but I think getting a 17rd mag with a 10rd mag kinda sucks. You have to go buy a $43 10rd mag so you can carry. I understand the 17 rounder can used for range but defeats the purpose in a way. My 2 pennies.:dunno:

just carry it as your reload for CC..... thats what im doing..

CharlestonG26
02-27-2010, 18:42
I just received an RMLowrider today. I can not begin to tell you how much I like it. Super comfortable. Highly recommended!!

+1...my EDC is a G26 in a RM Low Rider kydex holster. I carry appendix position and it is quite comfortable and offers excellent concealment.

Goldenboy007
08-16-2011, 23:54
I'm trying to choose between the G26 and SR9C for my wife (and perhaps my BUG). I have the gen 4 G19 so the G26 gets points for being able to use my G19 mags as well. But the SR9C is $100 cheaper ($150 less than than the gen 4 G26). And for that price difference, I can get a crimson trace laser for the sr9c.
Decisions, decisions.

John Biltz
08-17-2011, 05:41
I'm trying to choose between the G26 and SR9C for my wife (and perhaps my BUG). I have the gen 4 G19 so the G26 gets points for being able to use my G19 mags as well. But the SR9C is $100 cheaper ($150 less than than the gen 4 G26). And for that price difference, I can get a crimson trace laser for the sr9c.
Decisions, decisions.
That hundred will not go far if you have to buy magazines and the G26 is smaller. Saying that the smart man will let his wife choose.

cluznar
04-14-2012, 08:11
I just purchased a SR9c about 3 months ago. It is now my carry with 250 no problem rounds thru it. This gun has a nice trigger, low recoil and easy to shoot. Carry it with Hornady Critical Defense 115 gr ammo. Use a DeSantis IWB Sof-Tuck holster. Anyone that gets a chance to shoot one should not hesitate.

I believe it will be one of Ruger's biggest sellers. :tongueout:

racer88
04-14-2012, 13:28
Thanks for the responses. I went ahead, after handling all three, and got the Glock 26. Happy so far. Any recommendations for a thin, affordable Kydex holster ?

I carry my G27 in either a Crossbreed Supertuck or a White Hat Maxtuck every day.

cluznar
04-14-2012, 13:46
Take a good look at the holsters at N82Tactical.com they make some very nice ones. :cool:

Haldor
04-14-2012, 14:31
Thanks for the responses. I went ahead, after handling all three, and got the Glock 26. Happy so far. Any recommendations for a thin, affordable Kydex holster ?

Nothing has made my G26 more comfortable to carry than my Milt Sparks VM-II. It is not kydex and is pricy, but it makes the G26 a dream to carry. I have a whole drawer full of holsters for my G26, but the VM-II is the only inside the waist band holster I use. Here is a pic of my G26 in the VM-II.

http://i256.photobucket.com/albums/hh168/HaldorPhil/Guns/P1000036.jpg

If you are willing to go with an outside the waist-band holster check out the Galco Matrix M7X. It is a very thin and secure Kydex holster with two point belt suspension. Price is very reasonable, around $33.

http://www.usgalco.com/Catalog/large/M7X_SILO.jpg

http://www.usgalco.com/HolsterPT3.asp?ProductID=2776&CatalogID=4

The Galco matrix is very concealable with a cover garment. I bought it for my G17, but it works equally well with my G26. It really holds the butt of the pistol tight against your side and is very comfortable for sitting for extended periods.

http://www.usgalco.com/Catalog/large/CON-vs-pancake.jpg

packinaglock
04-14-2012, 17:30
I just received an RMLowrider today. I can not begin to tell you how much I like it. Super comfortable. Highly recommended!!

I have the Lowrider for my G23 & G19, G26 & G27, M&P 9c & .40c, & Kahr pm9, love these holsters! They're great for putting on or taking off, and comfortable too.

up1911fan
04-14-2012, 18:50
Check out the Y12 and K25 from Secret City Weaponeers. Tony does great work! He post's on here as Seraph.

dudel
04-15-2012, 14:55
For me, I'd take the G26 of the choices mentioned. I don't like magazine disconnects or trigger pull on the Ruger. Since i have other Glocks I like the limited number of extra spares I need to keep.

diamondd2
04-15-2012, 17:37
I sold my S&W M&P 40c for a G26 gen 4. The M&P was just to close to my 23 in size for me to justify it. The 26 is much more compact. Good choice.