Quick question regarding amt of powder for some first time loads [Archive] - Glock Talk

PDA

View Full Version : Quick question regarding amt of powder for some first time loads


KiloBravo
05-09-2010, 20:23
I want to work up a good target load in .45 ACP. I have brass, remington primers, Unique powder, and winchester 230 gr. FMJ-RN bullets as my limited components to start off with.

In my Hornady load manual, it says that the second up from the lightest powder charge for this particular bullet should be 5.4 gr. of the brand I have on hand. I guess I am just wondering if I should start off with that option, of if you guys might recommend that I start with the lowest printed data in the book. I have never reloaded before and would rather be safe than sorry. I def. don't want to get myself or my gun hurt for assuming anything when I honestly have no clue what I am doing. Other than from what research I have done.

If it matters, these will be shot from a steel framed, 5" brl 1911.

RustyFN
05-09-2010, 20:52
I always start at the recommended starting load but it's not a requirement. I would recommend to stay below the half way point of the powder charge to start and work up.

ilgunguygt
05-09-2010, 21:49
I always start at the recommended starting load but it's not a requirement. I would recommend to stay below the half way point of the powder charge to start and work up.
I never start at the min charge when loading for a semi-auto. I usually start somewhere more towards the middle. I know many will discredit this practice, but I no longer feel the need to make "test" rounds that I know wont cycle the action of the gun.

XDRoX
05-09-2010, 21:52
I load 6.0gr of Unique under 230gr plated RN at 1.260" and shoot them out of a 1911 as well.

My manual recommends 5.5gr - 6.5gr, so I'm right in the middle.

MarioS
05-09-2010, 22:42
For me personally, I start at the minimum starting load in the manual and just work up. I only load a small quantity so I don't waste components on test loads. You could also load 10 at starting load, and load another 10 with a .1 or .2 grain increase, depending on what your recipe. Just gives you more to work with in terms of gauging where you want your actual loading to be.

harleyfx69
05-09-2010, 22:58
if its a very broad spectrum powder, like 5.0 starting, 7.5 max (numbers out of my butt, no relavent associated powder) vs a load thats 5.0 start and 5.5 max,

that makes the difference for me, with the 5.0-7.5 ill go mid way, and usually end up with a happy load being a little under max,

where as the low variation powder i start at the minimum..

IndyGunFreak
05-10-2010, 06:52
I want to work up a good target load in .45 ACP. I have brass, remington primers, Unique powder, and winchester 230 gr. FMJ-RN bullets as my limited components to start off with.

In my Hornady load manual, it says that the second up from the lightest powder charge for this particular bullet should be 5.4 gr. of the brand I have on hand. I guess I am just wondering if I should start off with that option, of if you guys might recommend that I start with the lowest printed data in the book. I have never reloaded before and would rather be safe than sorry. I def. don't want to get myself or my gun hurt for assuming anything when I honestly have no clue what I am doing. Other than from what research I have done.

If it matters, these will be shot from a steel framed, 5" brl 1911.

If you're using the Auto Disk that comes w/ the LCT, it won't hit 5.4gr of Unique. Not sure what your load range is, but if you look at the chart that comes w/ your LCT and the Auto Disk, it will throw(that's in that range)....5.2, 5.6, 6.0, 6.5

Unique is one of those powders I don't care for to much with the Auto Disk.. It starts to "spread" quite at about .5 per cavity when you get around 5gr of Unique.

I bought an adjustable charge bar, but I'm not sure how it's going to work w/ 231. Haven't really put any effort into using it yet. Anyone ever used it the adj. charge bar w/ 231? From my reading, it should run well w/ WST, but I'm not out of 231 yet.

IGF

Colorado4Wheel
05-10-2010, 07:06
One reason to start with "starting" loads is they often don't cycle the slide or the shooter will notice them as being sluggish. It's nice to notice/feel that as the start so that you can confirm you really do have a underpowered load. Then when you work it up you get the feel the difference. I assume you don't have a chrono so this is your only chance to notice these differences.

das9mm26
05-10-2010, 07:26
My Dillon 550B won't throw more than 2 identical charges of Unique consecutively, try as I might.....I've finally resorted to weighing EACH charge individually (for 6.0 gr.).....time-consuming, but I'm in no hurry!!
Like the OP, I'm loading ONLY .45ACP right now....and using Hornady 230gr FMJ/RN bullets....My first loads were 6.0gr of Unique, based on the Lyman data (5.9 to 6.5gr); I used 6.0, figuring if the scale was "off" +/- .1gr., I'd still be OK on the "low" side....and well below the MAX....As it turns out, the 6.0 works very well in ALL my .45s - 1911s (5" AND 3") and Glocks (21SF and 36).
After I finish the Unique, I'm going to try Bullseye to see if it will meter more consistently....

XDRoX
05-10-2010, 07:39
My Dillon 550B won't throw more than 2 identical charges of Unique consecutively, try as I might.....I've finally resorted to weighing EACH charge individually (for 6.0 gr.).....time-consuming, but I'm in no hurry!!
Like the OP, I'm loading ONLY .45ACP right now....and using Hornady 230gr FMJ/RN bullets....My first loads were 6.0gr of Unique, based on the Lyman data (5.9 to 6.5gr); I used 6.0, figuring if the scale was "off" +/- .1gr., I'd still be OK on the "low" side....and well below the MAX....As it turns out, the 6.0 works very well in ALL my .45s - 1911s (5" AND 3") and Glocks (21SF and 36).
After I finish the Unique, I'm going to try Bullseye to see if it will meter more consistently....

BE does meter better than Unique, but it's really dirty. You should try some WST. Meters well and burns cleaner.

fredj338
05-10-2010, 12:04
I never start at the min charge when loading for a semi-auto. I usually start somewhere more towards the middle. I know many will discredit this practice, but I no longer feel the need to make "test" rounds that I know wont cycle the action of the gun.

I'm in this same camp. I find many starting loads just don't cycle well in some semiautos. So IMO, waste of time & components. I use three printed sources & the average middle charge wt. Load no more than 10rds, then 10rds 0.1gr up & 0.1gr down. Shoot them in order & note reliability, accuracy & any pressure signs (high or low). You can then work up or down to the level of vel you want,always watching gor pressure sings (flattened or piereced primers, case head markings, etc).

FlyfishermanMike
05-10-2010, 15:56
5.4 of Unique barely, barely cycles my G30. The brass basically spills out onto the table. 6.0 @ 1.260" is my typical load and the difference is huge! With Unique there is a pretty big spectrum between high and low. I'd recommend playing around to find what works best with your gun. Unique meters pretty well out of my Lee Perfect Powder Measurer.

zeke66
05-10-2010, 16:29
I bought an adjustable charge bar, but I'm not sure how it's going to work w/ 231. Haven't really put any effort into using it yet. Anyone ever used it the adj. charge bar w/ 231? From my reading, it should run well w/ WST, but I'm not out of 231 yet.

IGF
For me, the adj charge bar is a dream with W231. Much more consistent than with Unique. Once I'm dialed in, it's absoltuely dead-on. I can also throw ten charges and weigh them and the total is dead-on. Example; for a 4.8grn charge of W231, ten charges weigh exactly 48grns per my RCBS 505.

ilgunguygt
05-10-2010, 19:15
I'm in this same camp. I find many starting loads just don't cycle well in some semiautos. So IMO, waste of time & components. I use three printed sources & the average middle charge wt. Load no more than 10rds, then 10rds 0.1gr up & 0.1gr down. Shoot them in order & note reliability, accuracy & any pressure signs (high or low). You can then work up or down to the level of vel you want,always watching gor pressure sings (flattened or piereced primers, case head markings, etc).
Finally, someone who agrees with me! I just cant see wasting the time and components. Of course there are exceptions, but not usually.
For me, the adj charge bar is a dream with W231. Much more consistent than with Unique. Once I'm dialed in, it's absoltuely dead-on. I can also throw ten charges and weigh them and the total is dead-on. Example; for a 4.8grn charge of W231, ten charges weigh exactly 48grns per my RCBS 505.
I use a lee adjustable charge bar with AA#2, Bullseye, Power Pistol, 2400 with no problems. 700x, that was another story.

IndyGunFreak
05-10-2010, 19:18
For me, the adj charge bar is a dream with W231. Much more consistent than with Unique. Once I'm dialed in, it's absoltuely dead-on. I can also throw ten charges and weigh them and the total is dead-on. Example; for a 4.8grn charge of W231, ten charges weigh exactly 48grns per my RCBS 505.

Really? Hmm, I might have to break it out and give it a try.

Thanks for the info.

IGF

fredj338
05-11-2010, 01:50
Finally, someone who agrees with me! I just cant see wasting the time and components. Of course there are exceptions, but not usually.

I use a lee adjustable charge bar with AA#2, Bullseye, Power Pistol, 2400 with no problems. 700x, that was another story.
Starting loads are prudent, especially for newbs, but reality is a biatch & they often fail miserably in semiautos. A 5.4gr charge of Unique under a 230grFMJ would be around 700fps. My working load is 6gr & it barely makes 820fps.:dunno:

orgnova
05-11-2010, 03:52
6.0gr of Unique 230grFMJ @ 1.260 OAL - works in all my 45's. my 2.

Kwesi
05-11-2010, 07:39
My first 9mm loads are 5.0 gr WSF w/115 gr FMJ & the recommended start at 4.9. NO issues cycling full auto in the CA89K or semi in G17. Guess Ibwas fortunate.

coachg
05-11-2010, 08:50
If you're using the Auto Disk that comes w/ the LCT, it won't hit 5.4gr of Unique. Not sure what your load range is, but if you look at the chart that comes w/ your LCT and the Auto Disk, it will throw(that's in that range)....5.2, 5.6, 6.0, 6.5

Unique is one of those powders I don't care for to much with the Auto Disk.. It starts to "spread" quite at about .5 per cavity when you get around 5gr of Unique.

I bought an adjustable charge bar, but I'm not sure how it's going to work w/ 231. Haven't really put any effort into using it yet. Anyone ever used it the adj. charge bar w/ 231? From my reading, it should run well w/ WST, but I'm not out of 231 yet.

IGF

I have had success using 231 and the adjustable charge bar. For certain powders that little tool is great.

gwalchmai
05-11-2010, 13:02
I load 6.0gr of Unique under 230gr plated RN at 1.260" and shoot them out of a 1911 as well. +1. This is about the standard "hardball" equivalent load. I've gone up to 6.5 but it wasn't any better so I went back to 6.0 to spare the gun. Less recoil.

If you want a real sweet load try 4.5 - 5.0gr of Solo-1000 under that bullet. ;)

fredj338
05-11-2010, 13:05
+1. This is about the standard "hardball" equivalent load. I've gone up to 6.5 but it wasn't any better so I went back to 6.0 to spare the gun. Less recoil.

If you want a real sweet load try 4.5 - 5.0gr of Solo-1000 under that bullet. ;)
Nah! He's already been turned onto WST! Doesn't get much better in 45acp:wavey:

ilgunguygt
05-11-2010, 15:09
My first 9mm loads are 5.0 gr WSF w/115 gr FMJ & the recommended start at 4.9. NO issues cycling full auto in the CA89K or semi in G17. Guess Ibwas fortunate.
Not always. My 1911 cycles at most starting charges. My xd and glock will not. All are 45acp, too. I have yet to find a load that had best accuracy, reliability, and cleanliness at min charge. Almost without exception ts at the middle of the road and a little higher.

gwalchmai
05-11-2010, 15:25
Nah! He's already been turned onto WST! Doesn't get much better in 45acp:wavey:
WST is great, that's for sure. ;)

zeke66
05-11-2010, 21:21
I never start at the min charge when loading for a semi-auto. I usually start somewhere more towards the middle. I know many will discredit this practice, but I no longer feel the need to make "test" rounds that I know wont cycle the action of the gun.

Me too! I've learned my lesson loading for semi-auto pistols. No need wasting time with the lower end of the load data.

Call me a cowboy, but IMHO, most PUBLISHED data is a bit on the conservative side anyway. Don't get me wrong. I'm not for going out and just loading over published data just for the heck of it but I always start somewhere towards the middle.