Best CCW .357 sig round [Archive] - Glock Talk

PDA

View Full Version : Best CCW .357 sig round


kamonjj
09-09-2010, 21:37
I'd like to hear everyones opinion on this. I have read quite a bit about unreliable 357 sig ammo. I'm looking to get a good CCW round thats hollow point, and reliable.

Suggestions?

SanityAssassin
09-09-2010, 21:54
I'd like to hear everyones opinion on this. I have read quite a bit about unreliable 357 sig ammo. I'm looking to get a good CCW round thats hollow point, and reliable.

Suggestions?

Where have you read this? I've only fired about 200 rounds of hollow point ammo, but I've had no problems. No problems with any target ammo either (1500 rounds), a few problems with reloaded.

Only problems I've read about with 357 sig factory ammo was setback issues from when they first started to manufacture it - like 15 years ago.

Got a link to the unreliable ammo?

KaTooM
09-09-2010, 22:08
I use 125gr Federal premium hollow points. I cycle my HP ammo out once a year, and have been using it it for about seven years now. Cycles great, small fire ball, no set backs after re-chambering many times. I like it.

JBarbaresi
09-09-2010, 22:36
i switch up between HST's and GD. don't know what's necessarily "the best" though.

WoodenPlank
09-10-2010, 02:43
Ranger T/SXT for EDC, and a small supply of Gold Dot boxed up in the safe. No problems at all with the (limited) testing I have done, and 0 issues with practice ammo.

atl-g33
09-10-2010, 07:19
I carry ranger t's. 200 through my g33 and my p226 with zero problems at all. More range ammo with 0 problems.

kamonjj
09-10-2010, 08:43
Where have you read this? I've only fired about 200 rounds of hollow point ammo, but I've had no problems. No problems with any target ammo either (1500 rounds), a few problems with reloaded.

Only problems I've read about with 357 sig factory ammo was setback issues from when they first started to manufacture it - like 15 years ago.

Got a link to the unreliable ammo?

I'll dig up where I found that info. It doesn't scare me, and I haven't had any problems with any ammo I have put down range. I was just trying to gauge everyones opinion on carry ammo. They have nothing good near me for carry. Just mostly white box range ammo. Which leads me to have to make a purchase online for carry ammo.

Glockbuster
09-10-2010, 11:55
If there is a caliber that is virtually feed problem free it is the bottlenecked 357 sig. No small advantage for CCW.

I carry either a G32 or G31 loaded with Speer Gold Dots--125 grain. Great guns, great round....no problems whatsoever.

Donīt chamber your rounds more than twice before using them for practice ammo.

Iīd also be a happy clam carrying Federal, Winchester Ranger T, or whatever good hollowpoint ammo.

kamonjj
09-10-2010, 15:20
Where is everyone getting their ranger t from? A lot of sites I have come across say its for law enforcement only.

JBarbaresi
09-10-2010, 16:01
Where is everyone getting their ranger t from? A lot of sites I have come across say its for law enforcement only.

try ammotogo.com, not sure if they have any in stock currently but they usually carry it.

bac1023
09-10-2010, 19:24
I like Cor-Bon. :)

BurkGlocker
09-10-2010, 19:25
Ranger T/SXT or Federal HST...

Burk

WoodenPlank
09-11-2010, 00:28
try ammotogo.com, not sure if they have any in stock currently but they usually carry it.

That is a Winchester policy, not law. Most websites will sell it no problem. I scored some from Lucky Gunner recently for $30 per 50 round box. it dropped as low as 26 or so before they sold out.

Also, I have experienced ZERO setback issues with my Winchester ammo. Even rounds I purposefully rechambered over and over have has no issues. That being said, when loading my 32, I am generally careful with how hard I let the slide slam down after hand-chambering the round. Basically, I let it close JUST hard enough to get the extractor seated correctly.

atl-g33
09-11-2010, 14:27
sgammo.com still has some in stock I believe.

Glockbuster
09-13-2010, 09:24
That being said, when loading my 32, I am generally careful with how hard I let the slide slam down after hand-chambering the round. Basically, I let it close JUST hard enough to get the extractor seated correctly.


I would advice you against doing this. Though hard to believe, this method actually exerts more pressure on the bullet and would aid bullet setback. Also, it places additional stress on the extractor. Doing it that way pries out the extractor to get it to snap around the roundīs rim from behind, and might very well chip your extractor off.

The best way is just to normally rack the slide back and let go for chambering. In that way the round will sneak up behind the extractor in the breechface, and move right on into the chamber.

kamonjj
09-13-2010, 11:19
Luckily I found some ranger by my house. I'll be picking some up on wednesday when I can make it over there.

atl-g33
09-14-2010, 09:25
Luckily I found some ranger by my house. I'll be picking some up on wednesday when I can make it over there.

:thumbsup:

WoodenPlank
09-21-2010, 13:34
I would advice you against doing this. Though hard to believe, this method actually exerts more pressure on the bullet and would aid bullet setback. Also, it places additional stress on the extractor. Doing it that way pries out the extractor to get it to snap around the roundīs rim from behind, and might very well chip your extractor off.

The best way is just to normally rack the slide back and let go for chambering. In that way the round will sneak up behind the extractor in the breechface, and move right on into the chamber.

That actually makes sense.

Glockbuster
09-21-2010, 15:10
Adding a bit of technicality to the above, one must understand that the extractor is a tempered piece. That makes it strong but brittle. It is designed to pull the empty case out, thereafter the next round in the mag sneaks from under against the breechface, and it is pushed into position in the chamber and in this way the extractor is forced outward but from behind. This movement is natural to its design. But when it is forced outward from the front through the caseīs rim (if you chamber the round manually and then let the slide off, or even if you escort it forward), the movement is not according to design and may break the extractor. It is this same force that places additional pressure on the bullet that is now sitting against the barrelīs rifling, aiding in its setback.

WoodenPlank
09-21-2010, 16:14
Adding a bit of technicality to the above, one must understand that the extractor is a tempered piece. That makes it strong but brittle. It is designed to pull the empty case out, thereafter the next round in the mag sneaks from under against the breechface, and it is pushed into position in the chamber and in this way the extractor is forced outward but from behind. This movement is natural to its design. But when it is forced outward from the front through the caseīs rim (if you chamber the round manually and then let the slide off, or even if you escort it forward), the movement is not according to design and may break the extractor. It is this same force that places additional pressure on the bullet that is now sitting against the barrelīs rifling, aiding in its setback.

I had never sat down and thought about it before. Learn something new every day.

Glock940
09-21-2010, 19:20
I'd like to hear everyones opinion on this. I have read quite a bit about unreliable 357 sig ammo. I'm looking to get a good CCW round thats hollow point, and reliable.

Suggestions?


I never heard of this or read it anywhere. Do you have any links? I have shot many many 357 sig rounds with no problems at all. Hollow and ball both feed exceptionally well. I use 125gr Speer GD in my pistol when out and about, at the range I use what ever ball ammo I can find. I have been using Speer TMJ 125gr ammo lately at the range...when I can get there lol