Benefits Of External Extractor? [Archive] - Glock Talk

PDA

View Full Version : Benefits Of External Extractor?


The Expert
11-11-2010, 10:21
Is there a benefit to an external extractor on a 1911? I saw this picture recently and wondered it the selling point was just that it was different and different=good in a crowded market.

http://img819.imageshack.us/img819/2614/extextractor.jpg

nolt
11-11-2010, 10:29
if you are Sig Sauer then its a great way to bastardize the 1911 into something that is "Unmistakeably Sig!!"
(their words not mine.)
im struggling with anything else to add.

im not such a hater of EEs that i think youre going to hell for having one on a 1911 the way some people seem to be. but i dont own a 1911 that has one, and have no current plans for one.
i refuse to discredit or demean the work of smiths like PL that do incredible work with them. they just arent for me.

Quack
11-11-2010, 10:37
Some work (sig, s&w, PL) and some don't (Kimber)

cole
11-11-2010, 10:44
Some work (sig, s&w, PL) and some don't (Kimber)

This. IMO, when it works, it can work better than the traditional internal setup and for a longer period of time. IMO, there is a reason the external extractor is used on most modern guns. However, a properly tuned extractor (ideally, it comes that way from the factory) in a well-cared for 1911 will run reliably. Traditionalist, me included, prefer internal on a 1911.

bac1023
11-11-2010, 10:48
Is there a benefit to an external extractor on a 1911? I saw this picture recently and wondered it the selling point was just that it was different and different=good in a crowded market.

http://img819.imageshack.us/img819/2614/extextractor.jpg

Well, for Paul Liebenberg, he personally told me that he gets the best performance from them. He's basically the father of the external extractor in a 1911. While I prefer the looks of an internal, the external doesn't bother me. Liebenberg builds some of the best pistols in the world.


http://i473.photobucket.com/albums/rr97/briancut1023/000_3900-1.jpg

bac1023
11-11-2010, 10:50
Some work (sig, s&w, PL) and some don't (Kimber)

Unertl had it right too.

What a shame they're no more. :crying:


http://i473.photobucket.com/albums/rr97/briancut1023/000_1869.jpg

CAcop
11-11-2010, 10:59
The benefit of an external extractor is that if it starts going south you can either replace the extractor or the spring without having to worry about tuning. Just an armorer's point of view.

brisk21
11-11-2010, 11:03
Unertl had it right too.

What a shame they're no more. :crying:


http://i473.photobucket.com/albums/rr97/briancut1023/000_1869.jpg


Theyd probably be flourishing if there were more Bacs in the country!!!

bac1023
11-11-2010, 12:11
Theyd probably be flourishing if there were more Bacs in the country!!!

LOL!

Maybe so, but they were primarily a high end optics company. I'm honestly not sure what happened. :dunno:

http://www.unertloptics.com/

GVFlyer
11-11-2010, 12:15
I have 1911s with both internal extractors and external extractors - both function well.

Johan Beer
11-11-2010, 15:20
The external extractor is proven to be more reliable. Almost all modern pistols have them.

That being said, I'll take an internal on my 1911, thank you. Top tier 1911 companies know how to do it, and it looks much better.

Jim Watson
11-11-2010, 21:40
The benefit of an external extractor is that if it starts going south you can either replace the extractor or the spring without having to worry about tuning.

Smith & Wesson will tell you that you are not smart enough or well equipped enough to change out their external extractor; it takes the right gauge and torsion bar to fit one up.

Zombie Steve
11-11-2010, 21:42
Benefits Of External Extractor?


No one will steal your 1911.

bac1023
11-12-2010, 04:42
No one will steal your 1911.

:rofl:

JohnVal81
11-12-2010, 12:16
My Kimber has one and it works fine.

1006
11-12-2010, 19:53
I think the external ones have a wider operational envelope for lack of a better way to put it. EX: Almost every forty cal with an external extractor can be converted to 9mm with a simple barrel and mag change. And, they are easier to make and install for a new production line worker.

Tucson_1
11-12-2010, 22:59
My Kimber has one and it works fine.

I had a Kimber TLE II with an EE and it ran flawlessly. It seems to be hit or miss for Kimber though...

Speaking of missing, I miss that TLE. Should have kept that one...
http://i53.photobucket.com/albums/g66/jloftus/1106025.jpg

AA#5
11-12-2010, 23:05
The external extractor is proven to be more reliable. Almost all modern pistols have them.

That being said, I'll take an internal on my 1911, thank you. Top tier 1911 companies know how to do it, and it looks much better.

I have a gun with an internal extractor design that's the closest to a 1911's design I've ever seen.

It's an Uzi & so far I've fired 28,000 rounds through it without a malfunction or parts replacement - including the extractor. That's with 9mm and 45 acp.

1006
11-13-2010, 08:28
I am not sure the UZI is really a good comparison. I really don't know much about it. I think it fires with an open bolt; the extractor may be not much more than a guide for the exiting case.