School Question [Archive] - Glock Talk

PDA

View Full Version : School Question


Zut
11-29-2011, 20:09
One of my kids is a HS freshman. She has chosen President Kennedy's assassination as a topic for a presentation. She asked me for a spent shell casing to use as a visual aid. I gave her one, then got to thinking about the "zero tolerance" atmosphere prevalent in most schools. What do you guys think? Her teacher says no problem, but I worry that some lib student or teacher might freak out. Kid is a straight A student and very serious...

janice6
11-29-2011, 20:12
Like many things in today's world, it's out of your hands. Do what you think you should and P*** on it.

wrenrj1
11-29-2011, 20:19
One of my kids is a HS freshman. She has chosen President Kennedy's assassination as a topic for a presentation. She asked me for a spent shell casing to use as a visual aid. I gave her one, then got to thinking about the "zero tolerance" atmosphere prevalent in most schools. What do you guys think? Her teacher says no problem, but I worry that some lib student or teacher might freak out. Kid is a straight A student and very serious...

First, what is the relevance of the shell casing to the topic? meaning what does a spent shell casing add to the presentation vs. a PPT pic of one etc.

I hate to say it, as it's a pathetic point that we've become to this, but I'd want something from the principal in writing saying that it was OK. Otherwise, I'd make the point without a shell casing.

I don't have kids, but it seems like that's what our education system has become.

MeefZah
11-29-2011, 20:38
I would take a picture of the casing. Then, take a picture of the picture. Then, take a picture of the picture of the picture.

I think if it is thrice removed from reality you should be okay.

razdog76
11-29-2011, 21:36
I think if it is thrice removed from reality you should be okay.

I don't know, I seem to remember a thread about a kindergarten kid drawing a gun on paper, and getting suspended.:whistling:

toddmog
11-29-2011, 22:05
It also depends on your area. In my neck of the woods, camo and 4x4's are plentiful and hunting & shooting are the norm. I recently gave a HS student around 100 empty 12 GA hulls as well as 50 each .38 sp & 9mm casings. He needed them for some kind of presentation. There weren't any issues.

collim1
11-29-2011, 22:10
Golly I drove to HS everyday with a PSE bow in the back windshield. It is a shame what schools have become.

Hack
11-29-2011, 22:49
Heck, when I was in high school taking a pocket knife with you wasn't a sin; taking a rifle in your car, and keeping it there wasn't a sin; in fact with some schools you just checked it in the office, and picked it up at the end of the day.

But, I am from the age of the dinosaurs according to the younger set.

Now a days I would talk with the teacher, the principal, and maybe even a member of the school board; having it all on tape along with written assurances that the kid would not be hurt by this small thing.

razdog76
11-30-2011, 08:00
Golly I drove to HS everyday with a PSE bow in the back windshield. It is a shame what schools have become.

I have discussed this very thing with my coworkers. In college, I brought a vented rib shotgun barrel to use as an aid in giving a "how to" presentation of how to shoot clay pigeons. I could definately tell some people in the class were uneasy.

For something like this, how does the student know that she won't have that one, school official that lives in a different reality than everyone else? I would certainly want some clarification.

TKOFaith
11-30-2011, 08:31
One of my kids is a HS freshman. She has chosen President Kennedy's assassination as a topic for a presentation. She asked me for a spent shell casing to use as a visual aid. I gave her one, then got to thinking about the "zero tolerance" atmosphere prevalent in most schools. What do you guys think? Her teacher says no problem, but I worry that some lib student or teacher might freak out. Kid is a straight A student and very serious...

My son got a one day vacation for bringing empty casings to elementary school. YMMV

blueiron
11-30-2011, 11:30
Unless you get prior authorization in writing from the school district, don't bother. Take a photograph and put it into PowerPoint. All it takes is one fool to 'take offense' and there goes your child's academic career.

Firearms have been thoroughly vilified and no more so, than in academia.

For what it's worth, I lettered in JV and Varsity Rifle at my high school back in the day. Plenty of people called it a worthless sport even then, but it did me well in the Marines and in LE. The world has changed and not for the better.

scottydl
11-30-2011, 12:27
The school's concern (and justifiable IMO) is what if the casing got dropped by accident, and then someone finds it. Leads a reasonable person to believe there is a firearm in the school somewhere, i.e. mandatory lockdown, police swarm the area, evacuation, major deal. Context is everything.

Get it cleared with the principal (you do it or have the approving teacher do it) and make sure your daughter has a plan for when/where/how the casing will be stored and displayed during her presentation. You'd probably be okay in that case.

Numismatist
11-30-2011, 13:13
Heck, when I was in high school taking a pocket knife with you wasn't a sin; taking a rifle in your car, and keeping it there wasn't a sin; in fact with some schools you just checked it in the office, and picked it up at the end of the day.

But, I am from the age of the dinosaurs according to the younger set.

Now a days I would talk with the teacher, the principal, and maybe even a member of the school board; having it all on tape along with written assurances that the kid would not be hurt by this small thing.

I remember driving the High School and parking in the school lot and having the Principal come out and look at my shotgun in the truck, then we'd go to his truck and look at his...no worries. Nowadays, I'd be behind bars for that...:steamed:

blueberry1177
11-30-2011, 13:23
This is ridiculous it's a piece of brass at the most yet in today's world it's blown out of proportion. When i was in grade school I brought them in a zip lock bag to show my friends at lunch. Though looking back now I feel like if someone complained I would be in big trouble.

wrenrj1
11-30-2011, 19:42
I would take a picture of the casing. Then, take a picture of the picture. Then, take a picture of the picture of the picture.


I'd quadrople or quintuple with a picture of the principal holding a picture of the picture in front of the Superintendent of schools with a picture in front of the school board....:tongueout: