Winchester brass [Archive] - Glock Talk

PDA

View Full Version : Winchester brass


scccdoc
01-24-2012, 09:54
New to reloading,but have been very diligent in quality control. I've had very few FTF's (fire or feed)though I reload about five different brands.These include Winchester,Federal,Blazer, R&P (Remington),Speer,even PMC. The only real problem I have is with Winchester bought at Wally World,165's and 180's.About 20% fail to seat the Winchester primers that I use for all reloads.I spend more time reseating primers than I would like.I use a "Square Deal" and am quite satisfied because I stay ahead with the number of rounds fired by at least 1000 rds.Suggestions about the Winchester problem,please........DOC

firefighter4215
01-24-2012, 10:06
I assume from the weights of the bullets you mentioned that you're loading for 40's? I've used a lot of Winchester brass for the 40 and 38 special with no problems. You'd think that using Winchester primers AND brass together would be your best bet for trouble free loading. I'm using CCI 500s.

Outdoor Hub mobile, the outdoor information engine

rpgman
01-24-2012, 10:07
I use both an xl650 and a Lyman T-Mag II Turret press and I'm not having that issue, so I can't help.

But, I use some Winchester Cases with both Win and CCI Small pistol primers with no issues.

Greg

F106 Fan
01-24-2012, 10:08
I have been noticing some brass where the base is actually concave. In this case, with the shell holder essentially grabbing only the rim, the primer punch needs to be much higher.

Look at the brass and decide if the base looks proper. If not, you have a decision to make: separate and keep the brass, knowing you will have to adjust the primer punch to load it OR scrap it.

I don't have any new Winchester brass but some of the Federal 40 S&W certainly looks suspect.

Richard

FLSlim
01-24-2012, 10:12
I've never had a similar problem with Winchester brass in any cal. Maybe F106 has something that might help, check and see??

Rumbler_G20
01-24-2012, 10:16
I've used new Winchester rifle and pistol brass off and on for a long time. It is that brand that taught me it is indeed worth the time and trouble to always process new brass (including primer pocket uniforming) prior to use.


So yeah. I've had that problem. With both their pistol and rifle brass.:crying:

scccdoc
01-24-2012, 10:18
I assume from the weights of the bullets you mentioned that you're loading for 40's? I've used a lot of Winchester brass for the 40 and 38 special with no problems. You'd think that using Winchester primers AND brass together would be your best bet for trouble free loading. I'm using CCI 500s.

Outdoor Hub mobile, the outdoor information engine
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
Thanks for the reply firefighter.
Correct me if I am wrong,but CCI primers are larger in diameter.I will try anything to increase productivity and decrease frustration.:crying:..........DOC

scccdoc
01-24-2012, 10:27
[QUOTE=Rumbler_G20;18479352]I've used new Winchester rifle and pistol brass off and on for a long time. It is that brand that taught me it is indeed worth the time and trouble to always process new brass (including primer pocket uniforming) prior to use.


So yeah. I've had that problem. With both their pistol and rifle brass.:crying:
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
I did an "unscientific" study inspired by "Good brass vs bad brass" and found that the Winchester was the heavier of the brass that I posess.That would (in my mind) translate that into increased times that brass can be reloaded.Guess I'll try CCI's...........DOC

fredj338
01-24-2012, 10:37
What primers are you using? Many, myself included, have had issue sseating Wolf/Tula. They are not all round, kinda makes it an issue getting them in a round hole. Smallest dia primers I have found are the RP. I use them in certain rifle brass known to have small priner pokcets.

scccdoc
01-24-2012, 10:51
[QUOTE=fredj338;18479445]What primers are you using? Many, myself included, have had issue sseating Wolf/Tula. They are not all round, kinda makes it an issue getting them in a round hole. Smallest dia primers I have found are the RP. I use them in certain rifle brass known to have small priner pokcets.
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
Winchester small pistol.................

firefighter4215
01-24-2012, 12:57
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
Thanks for the reply firefighter.
Correct me if I am wrong,but CCI primers are larger in diameter.I will try anything to increase productivity and decrease frustration.:crying:..........DOC

I don't know the dimensions of any primers. I'm using an LCT, and have had no problems with the CCIs. I would say I've had no problems with RP, Win, and somr sort of Russian primer, buy I was given 100 of each to try, so that's not enough to know much with any confidence. I chose the CCI 500s because I was able to buy them locally for $29.99 + tax per thousand, and I thought that they worked pretty well. Maybe I've just been lucky. The price is up 10% now, but that's still ok with me compared to ordering a bazillion at once to get close to that price after the hazmat fee.

Outdoor Hub mobile, the outdoor information engine

ron59
01-24-2012, 13:28
Is it WIN brass or WCC?

WCC is Winchester's military version, it will have crimped primer pockets and be troublesome. But WIN brass is great, IMO.

WiskyT
01-24-2012, 16:51
I have been noticing some brass where the base is actually concave. In this case, with the shell holder essentially grabbing only the rim, the primer punch needs to be much higher.

Look at the brass and decide if the base looks proper. If not, you have a decision to make: separate and keep the brass, knowing you will have to adjust the primer punch to load it OR scrap it.

I don't have any new Winchester brass but some of the Federal 40 S&W certainly looks suspect.

Richard

ATK brands have been using the concave case head, Federal, Speer, Blazer. I notice no difference in loading or shooting it. It looks funny, but it works fine in 9mm on my Pro1000 and 40 on my 650.

F106 Fan
01-24-2012, 17:04
I haven't gotten around to loading any of the Federal 40 S&W but the brass sure looks strange.

Richard

scccdoc
01-24-2012, 21:37
Is it WIN brass or WCC?

WCC is Winchester's military version, it will have crimped primer pockets and be troublesome. But WIN brass is great, IMO.

^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

It is marked "WINCHESTER S&W 40"