Ed Brown EE Review and First Range Report Page 1 [Archive] - Glock Talk

PDA

View Full Version : Ed Brown EE Review and First Range Report Page 1


pdogkilr
04-04-2012, 15:04
Late in December of 2011 I ordered an Ed Brown Executive Elite from 1911 Heaven. CJ had it in my hands two days later.

The pistol arrived with an Ed Brown Pistol Case, two fired .45 ACP cases, a bottle of Ed Brown Gun Oil, one seven round magazine, and an Allen wrench for the grip screws.

Initial inspection showed a soft matte stainless steel finish. The finish was so smooth it almost appeared to be coated. There were no tool marks visible, and all edges had been softened. It was not a “Carry Melt” – just no sharp edges.

http://i70.photobucket.com/albums/i106/pdogkilr/Firearms/Ed%20Brown%20-%20Executive%20Elite/December%202011%20Review%20and%20Range%20Report/IMG_1813Editedforposting.jpg

http://i70.photobucket.com/albums/i106/pdogkilr/Firearms/Ed%20Brown%20-%20Executive%20Elite/December%202011%20Review%20and%20Range%20Report/IMG_1837LeftSideSized800.jpg

The grips are a dark brown Cocobolo (I believe) – not the reddish brown I expected. They are sharply checkered in a double diamond pattern. Attractive and “grippy”.

http://i70.photobucket.com/albums/i106/pdogkilr/Firearms/Ed%20Brown%20-%20Executive%20Elite/December%202011%20Review%20and%20Range%20Report/IMG_1844GripsSized800.jpg

Slide to Frame fitment was what you would expect from a custom pistolsmith. Tolerances are very close. The pistol came with a 16.5 pound recoil spring and there was no hesitation in slide movement when hand-cycling. I thought a “standard” mainspring was installed and the average of ten trigger pulls on a digital scale was four pounds fourteen point one ounces. There was zero creep and no over-travel. The break was very clean and crisp. A second shooter had a couple of unexpected double-taps due to the lack of take-up on the trigger. It was just something he was not used to.

The Executive Elite comes with a white outlined set of Trijicon Night Sights. The rear sight has a set screw to hold it in position. The front sight has an Allen screw that goes into a threaded hole in the dovetail slot to hold it in position. This hole is drilled all the way through the top of the slide.

http://i70.photobucket.com/albums/i106/pdogkilr/Firearms/Ed%20Brown%20-%20Executive%20Elite/December%202011%20Review%20and%20Range%20Report/IMG_1846RearSightSized800.jpg

The front strap and mainspring housing are checkered at 25 lines per inch. Not as abrasive as 20 LPI, but a little more so than the 30 LPI offerings from other vendors. After about 200 rounds, I put on a pair of Ten-Zero gloves. Gloved or not, proper indexing on the draw stroke was critical – the pistol does not move in your hand.

http://i70.photobucket.com/albums/i106/pdogkilr/Firearms/Ed%20Brown%20-%20Executive%20Elite/December%202011%20Review%20and%20Range%20Report/IMG_1848FrontStrapSized800.jpg

http://i70.photobucket.com/albums/i106/pdogkilr/Firearms/Ed%20Brown%20-%20Executive%20Elite/December%202011%20Review%20and%20Range%20Report/IMG_1852MSHousingSized800.jpg

The pistol disassembled easily with a nylon bushing wrench. Slide rails and frame rails were smooth with no visible tool marks. All machining and internal cuts were well executed. I wiped and re-oiled the rails, barrel hood and bushing. I ran a bore-snake through the bore to remove any oil that may have been left by the manufacturer.

I began the break-in over two range sessions one day apart. I did not clean the pistol between range trips. The first was at an indoor range, the second outdoor. Every fifty rounds I locked the slide back and put a drop of oil down the rear of each rail, and on the bushing end of the barrel. Then hand-cycled a few strokes to work the oil. Every 150 rounds I wiped and re-oiled the barrel hood.

Magazines used:
30 McCormick 8-Round Power Mags
2 McCormick 8-Round Shooting Stars
2 Wilson Combat 8-Round
4 Pachmayr 7-Round
1 Ed Brown 7-Round (Supplied with the pistol)
2 GI 7-Round (circa 1960 with original followers and springs)

Ammunition used:
350 Rounds – 200 Grain Lead SWC Handloads 5.6 grains W231
100 Rounds – 230 Grain Hornady FMC Handloads 5.5 grains W231
186 Rounds – 230 Grain FMC TulAmmo Factory hardball

I pre-loaded all the magazines with the lead SWC reloads. I would run two magazines, then rest the barrel a couple of minutes. I repeated this cycle through all magazines. After running all the magazines once – with no MALF’s, I used Power Mags to finish the ammunition.

pdogkilr
04-04-2012, 15:05
Sorry - had one too many pictures in the thread.

I had zero malfunctions during either session. I keep targets for record, and the one shown below is the first target used on the indoor range. It is the first 160 rounds of lead reloads. I ran 20 Power Mags and then pulled the target. The target was set at 15 yards and all firing was done offhand. The eyes will be 65 in the spring, so forgive the group size. I am certain the pistol is capable of much better accuracy. At the outdoor range we set the target at 25 yards, and it kept all rounds on an 8 inch “Shoot-n-See” stick-on target. Again, all firing was done offhand.

http://i70.photobucket.com/albums/i106/pdogkilr/Firearms/Ed%20Brown%20-%20Executive%20Elite/December%202011%20Review%20and%20Range%20Report/IMG_1833First160Sized800.jpg

After the range sessions, the EE was detail stripped and cleaned. My reloads tend to be on the dirty side. A careful inspection of the slide and frame showed no high spots. These would have been evidenced by shiny spots polished into the mating surfaces during firing. I know it was fired less than 700 rounds, but all mating surfaces looked “unfired”. I think this speaks well of the final fitting.

I ordered a five-pack of Ed Brown’s “competition” mainsprings per the recommendation on their web site. I expected a slight reduction in pull weight after I installed one. I was mistaken. The average of ten pulls on the digital scale once again was 4 lb. 14.1 oz. The only thing I can think of – the EE had a competition spring in it from the factory. Oh well, now I have spares “in stock”.

In my opinion, the fit, finish, and overall appearance of the Ed Brown Executive Elite is exceptional. I also believe the accuracy potential is excellent. Function so far has been flawless. After another 400 rounds (or so) I will move this pistol into the carry rotation.

Thanks for taking the time to read this.

Berto
04-04-2012, 18:43
Pretty amazing pistol and great shooting.
I'm guessing this runs the GI spring and plug, correct?

Ruggles
04-04-2012, 18:47
I think Brown builds the best looking 1911s on the market. :)

They are fine shooters to boot.

Great looking 1911 you have, but I think you need a few more mags to go with it :)

pdogkilr
04-04-2012, 18:58
I'm guessing this runs the GI spring and plug, correct?

Thanks - standard recoil spring and plug - "GI" looking recoil spring guide.

dakrat
04-04-2012, 19:04
amazing pistol! thanks for the review

bac1023
04-04-2012, 20:35
Awesome.

I've got a couple Browns and have been very happy with them.

Berto
04-04-2012, 21:31
Thanks - standard recoil spring and plug - "GI" looking recoil spring guide.

Very cool, I like it even more.:supergrin:

rahrah12
04-04-2012, 22:06
GReat post, beautiful pistol and nice shooting...

I have a KC and couldn't be happier with it...

38 Super Fan
04-04-2012, 22:26
http://images.sodahead.com/polls/000240569/polls_awesome_3432_231682_answer_1_xlarge.jpeg

Great review and gun!