SIG SAUER P229R Review [Archive] - Glock Talk

PDA

View Full Version : SIG SAUER P229R Review


plouffedaddy
08-24-2012, 13:20
http://i96.photobucket.com/albums/l178/tiffani33/Guns/IMG_0532.jpg

The SIG P229 was the first gun to be made exclusively in New Hampshire rather than Germany. US vs German made SIGs are a controversial subject in the SIG community but I don't care where the gun was made as long as it performs as I expect it to; and this gun does.

I currently have about 600 rounds this gun and below are a few of the pros and cons that I've found.

Pros:
-Reliable. This gun has never had a malfunction of any kind with any ammo I've fed it
-Accurate. The gun is easy to shoot well; especially in SA mode
-Ergonomic. The gun, with E2 grips, just feels great in the hand
-The Nitron finish on the slide is holding up well to holster wear
-Rail for attaching lights/accessories
-Aftermarket parts/holsters/support are widely available
-Standard DA trigger is smooth with little to no stacking
-SA trigger breaks crisply
-2x 15 round Mec-gar mags came with this gun

Cons:
-Cost. SIGs are generally overpriced relative to their competitors in my opinion
-Finish on the barrel is wearing more than I would expect for a gun of this quality
-The SA trigger has a good bit of take-up from the reset point (SRT greatly helps this however)

The video below shows some shooting from the 12m line, rapid fire from the 10m line with a shot timer to demonstrate the controllability of the pistol, a tabletop review and size comparison with the G19, and chronograph testing with Winchester Rangers, Gold Dots, and Federal HSTs:

http://youtu.be/0YtWT9IwhhA

Chronograph numbers:
-Winchester Ranger 115gr JHPs: 1136fps, 329 ft/lbs energy
-Speer Gold Dot 124gr JHPs: 1189fps; 389 ft/lbs energy
-Federal HST 124gr +p JHPs: 1170fps; 377 ft/lbs energy
http://i96.photobucket.com/albums/l178/tiffani33/Guns/IMAG1354.jpg

SigFTW
08-24-2012, 13:47
Great review! I have 5 Sigs and all are great shooters!

Beanie-Bean
08-24-2012, 14:40
Great review, PD. Looks like only one (two?) wardrobe changes :) I had to look back, because I recall that your shirt was a different color.

I've got two P229s (one rail-less .357, one with a rail in .40) and both are excellent to shoot. Nice thing is that they share the same magazines.

Looks like you got a great deal on an unfired gun there. Enjoy!

faawrenchbndr
08-24-2012, 15:16
Very nice,........great review!

Raven1967
08-24-2012, 19:40
Great review!

ctfireman
08-24-2012, 20:24
I need to get one back in my collection. They are so good lookin.

dnuggett
08-24-2012, 21:58
Sigs are great guns. My 229R has been fantastic.

SPIN2010
08-24-2012, 22:30
Custom Shop P229 here. :supergrin:

plouffedaddy
08-25-2012, 06:10
Great review, PD. Looks like only one (two?) wardrobe changes :) I had to look back, because I recall that your shirt was a different color.

I've got two P229s (one rail-less .357, one with a rail in .40) and both are excellent to shoot. Nice thing is that they share the same magazines.

Looks like you got a great deal on an unfired gun there. Enjoy!

I was out there shooting for a couple days----no wardrobe changes! :rofl:

I did get a pretty good deal---traded for a gun that I paid $610 OTD for. Tough to complain about that.

skeeter7
08-25-2012, 06:35
I just bought a brand spankin' new one on Gunbroker a few days ago. Picking it up on Friday due to the waiting period. Can't wait to shoot it...

oldsoldier
08-25-2012, 11:04
I have a SIG P229 SAS2T. I prefer guns without accessory rails. I've only put a little over 1K rds through it but no malfunctions so far. I've owned Glock and XD pistols in .40 and the P229 is my favorite by far. It's the only pistol I own now in .40.

plouffedaddy
08-25-2012, 20:05
I have a SIG P229 SAS2T. I prefer guns without accessory rails. I've only put a little over 1K rds through it but no malfunctions so far. I've owned Glock and XD pistols in .40 and the P229 is my favorite by far. It's the only pistol I own now in .40.

I prefer guns with them---even if I don't intend to use them. I don't think they look bad and I always like the option of putting a light on should I feel the need to do so.

But I guess that's why SIG makes both....:dunno:

ShaneS
08-25-2012, 20:32
I traded for a LNIB Sig P229r with a fellow GT forum member. I really like it, and it has been completely reliable and very accurate. It is a pleasure to shoot. I don't plan to use lights and lasers but like the rails anyway.

Dawolf
08-25-2012, 20:34
Thanks for the review.

bunk22
08-25-2012, 20:49
Excellent review! I don't have a 229 but own a P226 Navy and 2022. Both fine weapons, wouldn't mind getting a 229.

NeverMore1701
08-25-2012, 20:59
Not a fan of pistols with rails, but the 229 is an outstanding gun. Almost as good as the 228 :supergrin: