Please recommend a powder for 200gr XTP... [Archive] - Glock Talk

PDA

View Full Version : Please recommend a powder for 200gr XTP...


alank2
09-18-2012, 20:37
Hi,

I've been running 1.250" oal with 9.6gr of AA#7, CCI 300 LP.

Glock barrel: Avg 1044, sd 11, es 42, temp 85 F, n=10, G20

Storm Lake barrel (factory length): Avg 1108, sd 14, es 43, temp 70 F, n=10, G20 SL

I see some primer flattening - nothing severe, and more on some rounds than others so I am looking for another powder to try that will meter well and produce the same velocity and lower pressure - any ideas on what I should try?

Thanks,

Alan

ctious
09-18-2012, 20:50
Longshot.

Taterhead
09-18-2012, 20:53
Accurate no. 9.

I have tried Blue Dot, 800-X, and Longshot as well. I can't get to the same velocities of A9 without significantly loading past book loads with the other powders. I like A7 too, but not for pushing maxes.

Working up toward the Hornday max, I get to 1200 fps with a 200 gr XTP just below the book max. This is in my G20 with stock barrel. That load is higher than the Accurate max, but less than the Hornday max. Both loads are published for the XTP specifically. A9 meters as well as A7, and is much more suitable for the 200 gr bullets.

Of course, I hand weigh all charges that approach max - even A9.

alank2
09-18-2012, 20:58
Hi Taterhead,

Is the AA#9 a compressed load?

Thanks,

Alan

nickE10mm
09-19-2012, 11:24
Longshot is my personal fav and you will easily hit 1050-1100 with a book charge, but I've not yet messed with AA9. AA7 is another favorite of mine but, as has been said before, its not ideal for 200gr bullets. If it were, I'd probably use it more than BD... Also, 800x is GREAT for velocity but won't safely meter....

alank2
09-19-2012, 15:29
Hi,

One of the 35 rounds I shot the other day (200gr xtp, 1.250" oal with 9.6gr of AA#7, CCI 300 LP) was odd - the outside of the case was much more sooty than the others. I noticed it after firing it and 3 hours of corncob didn't polish the black off of it while the other cases came out gleamy bright. The primer doesn't look any flatter on it than the others... Any ideas?

Is AA#9 just as fine as AA#7?

Thanks,

Alan

nickE10mm
09-19-2012, 15:35
Hi,

One of the 35 rounds I shot the other day (200gr xtp, 1.250" oal with 9.6gr of AA#7, CCI 300 LP) was odd - the outside of the case was much more sooty than the others. I noticed it after firing it and 3 hours of corncob didn't polish the black off of it while the other cases came out gleamy bright. The primer doesn't look any flatter on it than the others... Any ideas?

Is AA#9 just as fine as AA#7?

Thanks,

Alan

USUALLY, the soot means that you have too low of a charge ... and the seal isn't strong enough and gas and soot comes back and gets on the case. I have a lot of that with lower charged Longshot loads. I don't have a manual in front of me so I don't know if your AA7 charges are hot-book or medium-book so I can't tell you for sure that's what's happening. I personally think that AA7 and AA9 flatten primers more than other powders because they are such small, fine, sand-like particles that get down in the primer pocket and flatten them. Try using case expansion instead of primer flattening to guesstimate pressure next round. Just an idea.

AA7 is faster than AA9 and, while its a GREAT powder, I think AA9 is better for the heavier bullets as its slower.

alank2
09-19-2012, 15:39
Hi,

I'm between trying long shot and AA#9. I keep reading about how LS meters poorly - how poorly are we talking about in a Dillon measure? +/- 0.1 ? +/- 0.2 ? Does it meter worse than blue dot?

Thanks,

Alan

nickE10mm
09-19-2012, 15:43
No powder will ever meter like Accurate 7 & 9 but Longshot meters great! Even better than BD

alank2
09-19-2012, 16:20
Hi,

Is there official 200gr XTP data for long shot? I didn't see it on their website...

edit - nevermind I found it!

Thanks,

Alan

ctious
09-19-2012, 17:50
Longshot meters great for me.

alank2
09-19-2012, 17:55
Hi,

I picked up some Longshot tonight - got Bass Pro to match a local store. They wanted $29.99 for it, but I got it for $19.99...

Anyone have a softer shooting XTP 200gr load to recommend? oal?

Thanks,

Alan

nickE10mm
09-19-2012, 19:01
Bps' rate on LS is ridiculous but they do that here too. Graf's sells it for 22$ all day long.

Good choice in powder though. You will like it.

7.3gr under a 200gr XTP's Hornady 8th's max and its very conservative. You wil be fine there.

Taterhead
09-19-2012, 22:21
Hi Taterhead,

Is the AA#9 a compressed load?

Thanks,

Alan

Nope.

Taterhead
09-19-2012, 22:28
Hi,

One of the 35 rounds I shot the other day (200gr xtp, 1.250" oal with 9.6gr of AA#7, CCI 300 LP) was odd - the outside of the case was much more sooty than the others. I noticed it after firing it and 3 hours of corncob didn't polish the black off of it while the other cases came out gleamy bright. The primer doesn't look any flatter on it than the others... Any ideas?

Is AA#9 just as fine as AA#7?

Thanks,

Alan

Nick pretty well covered this. You are not getting a good bore seal. The case acts like a gasget. The pressure of the load might not be enough to get a good seal. I also agree with the primer flattening hypothesis. I have observed this with most every load with A7 & A9. I have started messing with A5 a bit for plinkers, but I have not paid attention to see if it does the same. It is the same powder shape as its slower-burning siblings.

A9 & A7 look identical. That is if you buy the powders made in the same location. A few years ago, A7 & A9 were made in Belgium. They look just like each other. They are both now made in the USA (gotta like production on-shoring!). Both look different than the Belgian-made stuff, but otherwise look the same as each other.

In other words, A9 meters as superbly as does A7.

alank2
09-20-2012, 06:12
Hi,

Thanks guys. I loaded up 10 test rounds last night; I thought LS metered great. I ended up loading:

Winchester 10mm Brass (1F), Hornady XTP 200gr (.400), Hodgdon Longshot 7.5gr, CCI Large Pistol (#300), 1.250 oal

My SL barrel seems to like the crimp in the 0.4205 or smaller. At 0.421 or larger, the round doesn't drop in freely and fall out freely.

Thanks,

Alan

OhioGlockMan
09-20-2012, 10:56
My experience has shown me that blue dot is the best powder for the 200 weight range. Your going to want to be in the 9-9.5 ish charge weight range to get to 1200 FPS

alank2
09-20-2012, 17:24
Hi,

Wow the longshot rounds shot great! I'll post up the chrono info later on tonight. I shot them next to my AA#7 load (9.6gr) and the longshot load felt much better. The AA#7 feels too fast.

Thanks,

Alan

Cwlongshot
09-20-2012, 18:03
I am also working up a loading with Longshot and a 200XTP. I loaded to 9g with zero pressure signs...

6"KKM barrel and a G20...

CW

alank2
09-20-2012, 18:44
Hi CW,

What oal are you loading to?

My chrono results:

Winchester 10mm Brass (1F), Hornady XTP 200gr (.400), Hodgdon Longshot 7.5gr, CCI Large Pistol (#300), 1.250 oal

Avg 1060, sd 13, es 39, temp 85 F, n=10 G20 with SL barrel

Thanks,

Alan

nickE10mm
09-20-2012, 21:05
I am also working up a loading with Longshot and a 200XTP. I loaded to 9g with zero pressure signs...

6"KKM barrel and a G20...

CW

Same load I use regularly for hunting with 6" fully supported barrels and new brass. STOUT, over max, but very very nice.

**TO ALL SEEING THIS: Please do your own workups!!!**

Cwlongshot
09-21-2012, 04:06
Hi CW,

What oal are you loading to?

My chrono results:

Winchester 10mm Brass (1F), Hornady XTP 200gr (.400), Hodgdon Longshot 7.5gr, CCI Large Pistol (#300), 1.250 oal

Avg 1060, sd 13, es 39, temp 85 F, n=10 G20 with SL barrel

Thanks,

Alan

Max that will feed thru my mag. 1260 IIRC...

CW

gofastman
09-22-2012, 11:47
I personally think that AA7 and AA9 flatten primers more than other powders because they are such small, fine, sand-like particles that get down in the primer pocket and flatten them. Try using case expansion instead of primer flattening to guesstimate pressure next round. Just an idea.
I have heard this before, maybe it was from you, or someone echoing what you had said, I don't remember.
it does sound reasonable though, that stuff (AA#9 in my case) is super fine.

To the op:
I have not found anything that meters too much better than Longshot in my LEE powder thrower, and its great for velocity.

AA9 clogs up my Lee thrower because it is so fine, YMMV.

Go with Blue Dot if you want fireworks, that stuff is just too fun!

Cwlongshot
09-22-2012, 12:06
Just a note on pressures and watching for them...

Measuring case heads IS a accurate way if all things are equil. BUT at pressures under 40K it's simply not gonna happen. Meaning most handgun loadings cannot be accurately estimated by measuring the case head expansion. By the time you see measurable expansion your already past the SAMMI spec for this caliber. The 10mm is right on the cusp of this 40K pressure limits so it's possible some measurable expansion will be found.

Primers alone are a POOR choice for looking at pressures. YES hi pressures will likley have flattened primers. BUT you need to know what your looking at and this comes with experience.

Noise, excessive recoil as well as flattens primers and as you get to the top pressures case head expansion.

As mentioned, be careful and watch all signs of excessive pressure if your gonna push the limits and find your own maximum. Once you reach the limits, your best served to back off and set your guns limit for BEFORE pressure signs appear.

CW

nickE10mm
09-23-2012, 17:36
I have heard this before, maybe it was from you, or someone echoing what you had said, I don't remember..

I've said it before but I think I originally got the original post in this forum was by Yondering... can't recall