Gen4 Glock 32 Failure to feed. [Archive] - Glock Talk

PDA

View Full Version : Gen4 Glock 32 Failure to feed.


hamster
10-08-2012, 09:19
Well I finally got to the range with my Gen4 G32. Unfortunately it was a complete nightmare and I don't yet understand what is going on.

The Pistol: Gen 4 Glock 32, August 2012 build date. Came with 3 ambi-cut mags with a follower marked #2 .357/10

The Ammo: Georgia Arms Speer GDHP.

Eager to unleash some .357 at the paper target, I loaded my first mag with 10 rounds of the Georgia arms GDHP. The first round chambered with no problems. Fired nicely and extracted. Thats when the problems started. The next round got hung up on the bottom of the feed-ramp and never fed out of the magazine. So I drop the mag, make sure all the rounds are seated... rince and repeat. Same problem over and over.

Finally I tried the other mags. All three mags exhibited the same behavior. Interestingly, when I hand cycle the mag, everything extracts and feeds properly.

When I got home, I measured the cartridges from Georgia arms and found them to be ever so slightly longer than some Winchester PDX1s I had laying around possibly out of spec?

Unfortunately I didn't have any other style mags or ammo to try on this first outing with the G32.
Anyone have similar experiences? Any ideas?

Beanie-Bean
10-08-2012, 12:28
Sorry to hear about that, hamster. I've only shot commercial ammo from Speer, American Eagle/Federal, and Hornady through mine:

Speer 125 gr. Lawman TMJ
Speer 125 gr. Gold Dot
AE 125 gr. FMJ
Hornady 115 gr. Critical Defense

I load my own ammo for this caliber to practice with now, and use Speer 125 gr. TMJ with OAL of 1.135" Both of the commercial FMJ/TMJ ammo were the same length or shorter, and they fed through Glock magazines just fine. I used both the G32 Gen4 13-round magazines, as well as some G31 15-round magazines which weren't Gen4. No problems.

What was the OAL on the Georgia Arms ammo?

SJ 40
10-08-2012, 13:16
Hamster
This is what I have for the latest followers for 357 and the revision date is 1/24/12
SP 01593-2

Magazine Follower - .357 9-rd, 11-rd, 13-rd, & 15-rd mags only - current follower is marked .357 & 2

From that I would say your magazines have the latest followers. I also think that what you describe as your problem would lead me to suspect a magazine feeding issue.
If it were me and I had any older Gen 3 magazines I would try that in the gun and see what the results were. SJ 40

hamster
10-08-2012, 13:47
Hamster
This is what I have for the latest followers for 357 and the revision date is 1/24/12
SP 01593-2

Magazine Follower - .357 9-rd, 11-rd, 13-rd, & 15-rd mags only - current follower is marked .357 & 2

From that I would say your magazines have the latest followers. I also think that what you describe as your problem would lead me to suspect a magazine feeding issue.
If it were me and I had any older Gen 3 magazines I would try that in the gun and see what the results were. SJ 40

I actually did I have the same problem with an older non-ambi Mag that I have. Problem is I don't know the exact age of that one since I got it off GT. It has the #2 follower as well. All I know is it isn't the Ambi-Cut.

I'll have to measure the OAL of the Georgia arms rounds again as soon as a I get a chance later this afternoon.

davsco
10-08-2012, 14:28
sorry to hear of your problems. i just shot my gen 4 g32 for the first time last weekend. two boxes of fed fmj and a box of gold dots. only issue was the slide not locking back after each mag was dry, could be the aftermarket extended slide release i put on. it definitely works to release the slide.

other than that, zero issues, worked just as great as i expected.

hamster
10-08-2012, 14:57
Ok, here are a handfull of cartridges I randomly measured from the bag of 50

Georgia Arms 125 GR JHP Speer Bonded Unicore, OAL:
1.1330
1.1400
1.1390
1.1310
1.1430
1.1485
1.1335
1.1395

SJ 40
10-08-2012, 15:04
Ok, here are a handfull of cartridges I randomly measured from the bag of 50

Georgia Arms 125 GR JHP Speer Bonded Unicore, OAL:
1.1330
1.1400
1.1390
1.1310
1.1430
1.1485
1.1335
1.1395Well you found your culprit.
I have never shot any of that brand and I won't be from those results,thankfully I reload. SJ 40

hamster
10-08-2012, 15:17
Well you found your culprit.
I have never shot any of that brand and I won't be from those results,thankfully I reload. SJ 40

Forgive me for my ignorance here, but all I know is which direction my "boolitz" should face in the mag.

What would you expect the range of OALs to look like? Are the cartridges too long, too short? What is the largest acceptable variation from the norm?

I'd hope that too short should not be a problem. I've even read of folks on the Sig Forum being able to feed spent shells through their sigs with no feeding issues.

Beanie-Bean
10-08-2012, 15:32
hamster,

I just looked at my load data, and the OAL I'm good with on my .357SIG loads is 1.135" (not the other value which I stated earlier.)

Looking at my load manuals, the max length for .357SIG is 1.140" The slightly longer ones may be the ones giving you problems.

I didn't want to mention any SIG pistols on this post, because you were having problems specifically with the G32 Gen4, but now that you've mentioned the SIG pistols, I'll go on to say that I shot the same loads with a G22 w/G31 barrel, a SIG P229, and the G32. Both Glocks were Gen4 models.

Oh yeah, I've got the crimp die set to 0.379" and don't have problems with setback, either.

Hope this info helps.

SJ 40
10-08-2012, 15:55
Forgive me for my ignorance here, but all I know is which direction my "boolitz" should face in the mag.

What would you expect the range of OALs to look like? Are the cartridges too long, too short? What is the largest acceptable variation from the norm?

I'd hope that too short should not be a problem. I've even read of folks on the Sig Forum being able to feed spent shells through their sigs with no feeding issues.If I were loading the ammunition myself for myself I with 357 Sig would look at 1.135 as my target OAL

Georgia Arms 125 GR JHP Speer Bonded Unicore, OAL:
1.1330
1.1400
1.1390
1.1310
1.1430
1.1485
1.1335
1.1395
If your numbers are correct your OAL varies by,.
090,frankly I 'm surprised that a cartridge 1.1400 doesn't catch here and there in your magazine. SJ 40

hamster
10-08-2012, 16:37
Im going to go back and measure them all. I'm not sure if the in-spec one are that way from being jammed into the feed ramp? Perhaps they were all too long,

What factory ammo would y'all recommend I try next?

txgunguy
10-08-2012, 16:53
I had a G33 that did the same thing. Glock re-designed their 357 feed ramp to more of a flat profile. The older profile was sort of a semi circle, like the 9mm feed ramps.

Every brand of HP and some FMJ would not feed properly in that 33. I got my money back from the guy I bought it from. He sold it to me and knew it had issues.

I could have sent it back to glock but I was too pissed.

I tried 4 different magazines, all with latest followers and one mag with the old follower. I put a 27 barrel in it and it fed flawless. I THINK, that the ramp was cut a hair too short causing the rounds to hang up.

voyager4520
10-08-2012, 17:26
Are these limited capacity 10-round magazines or standard capacity 13-round magazines?

I'm not sure if there's another type of follower you could use in .357 10-round magazines. I know with 9mm 10-round magazines you can use 9mm3 followers if you experience failures to feed with the original 10-round followers. Perhaps .40 #5 followers would work in .357 10-round magazines.

The first thing I'd try is different ammo, I've never shot .357SIG so I couldn't make any recommendations but Speer Gold Dot 125gr may be a good place to start.

There seemed to be a problem in some .357SIG models, particularly G32's and G33's where the feed ramp seemed to be the culprit. The only solution for a lot people was to use an aftermarket barrel that had the older feed ramp design, I think a lot of people used KKM barrels and that fixed it for them.

Glock's recent extractors seem to have more variation in their specs and be more likely to fit too tight causing failures to feed, if nothing else seems to work you might try a replacement .357/.40 LCI extractor.

SJ 40
10-08-2012, 17:46
I found this,it has some good information and data. It shows the Max. OAL at 1.140.
Most commercial loadings of it run from 1.135 to 1.140 none shorter none longer.
http://www.realguns.com/Commentary/comar65.htm
SJ 40

hamster
10-08-2012, 18:40
Are these limited capacity 10-round magazines or standard capacity 13-round magazines?

I'm not sure if there's another type of follower you could use in .357 10-round magazines. I know with 9mm 10-round magazines you can use 9mm3 followers if you experience failures to feed with the original 10-round followers. Perhaps .40 #5 followers would work in .357 10-round magazines.

The first thing I'd try is different ammo, I've never shot .357SIG so I couldn't make any recommendations but Speer Gold Dot 125gr may be a good place to start.

There seemed to be a problem in some .357SIG models, particularly G32's and G33's where the feed ramp seemed to be the culprit. The only solution for a lot people was to use an aftermarket barrel that had the older feed ramp design, I think a lot of people used KKM barrels and that fixed it for them.

Glock's recent extractors seem to have more variation in their specs and be more likely to fit too tight causing failures to feed, if nothing else seems to work you might try a replacement .357/.40 LCI extractor.

They were 13 rounders.

clarkstoncz
10-08-2012, 20:49
Yes, the street/highway proven 125 gr Gold Dot is an excellent starting point.

I do hope you can get your problems worked out. 99% it's the ammo:)

dkf
10-08-2012, 21:01
The Speer factory Gold Dot ammo (both 53918 and 54234) are loaded to a OAL of 1.125". The Speer Gold Dot .357sig bullets are some of the hardest to feed because of the wide HP cavity. Federal HSTs, Hornady XTPs, pretty much all FMJs and etc feed smoother than Gold Dots. The HST is the best feeder I have shot through my sig guns.

The SAAMI max OAL for the .357sig is 1.140". I loaded some of my .357sig reloads to test with a new bullet and set them out to 1.150" and a few would hang up on the feed ramp on a gun that never malfunctioned before. Thus I found where OAL affects reliability, thus I shortened the OAL up.

Both my G32 and G33 have the newer barrels with the narrower feed ramp and the #2 followers and have had not malfunctions (other than my long OAL test reloads) Try some FMJ like Speer Lawman, S&B, Federal and etc to see if you have issues. The variation in OAL on the rounds you posted seems very large to me. I try to keep my reloads better than +- .003" variation from the targeted OAL.

hamster
10-08-2012, 21:28
That factory Speer sounds close to the factory winchesters I measured at 1.127. I will have to try different rounds.

I'm willing to blame the ammo, but this is the first glock jam I've ever had. Definitely has me worried.

The Speer factory Gold Dot ammo (both 53918 and 54234) are loaded to a OAL of 1.125". The Speer Gold Dot .357sig bullets are some of the hardest to feed because of the wide HP cavity. Federal HSTs, Hornady XTPs, pretty much all FMJs and etc feed smoother than Gold Dots. The HST is the best feeder I have shot through my sig guns.

The SAAMI max OAL for the .357sig is 1.140". I loaded some of my .357sig reloads to test with a new bullet and set them out to 1.150" and a few would hang up on the feed ramp on a gun that never malfunctioned before. Thus I found where OAL affects reliability, thus I shortened the OAL up.

Both my G32 and G33 have the newer barrels with the narrower feed ramp and the #2 followers and have had not malfunctions (other than my long OAL test reloads) Try some FMJ like Speer Lawman, S&B, Federal and etc to see if you have issues. The variation in OAL on the rounds you posted seems very large to me. I try to keep my reloads better than +- .003" variation from the targeted OAL.

dkf
10-08-2012, 22:06
Yeah the large factory ammo makers usually load at 1.125" OAL for the .357sig. That is at least what I have found with the rounds I have measured.

TxGlock9
10-08-2012, 22:40
I've had the EXACT same problems when I had my gen3 G32 shooting 1000rds of GA arms ammo. Oddly enough when I shot my gen4 G22 with 31 conversion barrel I NEVER had any problems with the same type of ammo. I do not own the gen3 32 any longer. Goodbye and good riddance.

DannyR
10-08-2012, 22:45
Stick with Speer Lawman or American Eagle for practice ammo. Georgia Arms reloads, while cheap, are inconsistent in quality.

avenues165
10-09-2012, 00:19
I bought a G32 barrel for my G23. It has a narrow, flat feedramp when compared to a .40 barrel. With the 5-petal GDs it has been flawless.

hamster
10-09-2012, 05:53
I've had the EXACT same problems when I had my gen3 G32 shooting 1000rds of GA arms ammo. Oddly enough when I shot my gen4 G22 with 31 conversion barrel I NEVER had any problems with the same type of ammo. I do not own the gen3 32 any longer. Goodbye and good riddance.

Did the same happen with other rounds as well? What did you replace the G32 with?

DannyR
10-09-2012, 06:08
When experiencing obvious ammo issues, it is wiser to make another ammo choice than to replace the pistol or barrel.:upeyes:

hamster
10-09-2012, 06:52
When experiencing obvious ammo issues, it is wiser to make another ammo choice than to replace the pistol or barrel.:upeyes:

I'm going to try a different brand of ammo because as has been said, that is my #1 suspect. Probably their round nose stock still would have been fine, but with the GDHP, the out of spec just plain causes failures.

I will say, this is the worst experience I've ever had with any handgun/ammo combination and has shaken my confidence in the pistol even though logically I know it is most likely not at fault. I will have to shoot at least 300 rounds without a hiccup before I'd feel comfortable carrying it at this point. This experience just goes to prove how critical it is to test HP carry loads as well as practice loads... you just never know.

Now I just need to find 300 reasonably priced .357 sig rounds. :)

voyager4520
10-09-2012, 06:54
The fact that your followers are marked .357/10 and "2" is strange, that sounds more like a 10-round magazine designation for followers.

From the latest Glock parts list:
SP 01593-2 Magazine Follower - .357 9-rd, 11-rd, 13-rd, & 15-rd mags only - current follower is marked .357 & 2
SP 01009 Magazine Follower - .357 10-rd G31-G32 mags only - marked .357/10 & 1

Perhaps there's a new 10-round follower marked ".357/10 2" instead of ".357/10 1" that Glock accidentally put into your magazines. Still I would try different ammo first.

dpadams6
10-09-2012, 07:21
sorry to hear of your problems. i just shot my gen 4 g32 for the first time last weekend. two boxes of fed fmj and a box of gold dots. only issue was the slide not locking back after each mag was dry, could be the aftermarket extended slide release i put on. it definitely works to release the slide.

other than that, zero issues, worked just as great as i expected.
There has been others here reporting problems with that extended slide release. Why I would always keep everything STOCK for ccw

dpadams6
10-09-2012, 07:22
Well I finally got to the range with my Gen4 G32. Unfortunately it was a complete nightmare and I don't yet understand what is going on.

The Pistol: Gen 4 Glock 32, August 2012 build date. Came with 3 ambi-cut mags with a follower marked #2 .357/10

The Ammo: Georgia Arms Speer GDHP.

Eager to unleash some .357 at the paper target, I loaded my first mag with 10 rounds of the Georgia arms GDHP. The first round chambered with no problems. Fired nicely and extracted. Thats when the problems started. The next round got hung up on the bottom of the feed-ramp and never fed out of the magazine. So I drop the mag, make sure all the rounds are seated... rince and repeat. Same problem over and over.

Finally I tried the other mags. All three mags exhibited the same behavior. Interestingly, when I hand cycle the mag, everything extracts and feeds properly.

When I got home, I measured the cartridges from Georgia arms and found them to be ever so slightly longer than some Winchester PDX1s I had laying around possibly out of spec?

Unfortunately I didn't have any other style mags or ammo to try on this first outing with the G32.
Anyone have similar experiences? Any ideas?
very odd for a 32 to have problems. I would try other ammo before blaming your 32.

dpadams6
10-09-2012, 07:27
The Speer factory Gold Dot ammo (both 53918 and 54234) are loaded to a OAL of 1.125". The Speer Gold Dot .357sig bullets are some of the hardest to feed because of the wide HP cavity. Federal HSTs, Hornady XTPs, pretty much all FMJs and etc feed smoother than Gold Dots. The HST is the best feeder I have shot through my sig guns.

The SAAMI max OAL for the .357sig is 1.140". I loaded some of my .357sig reloads to test with a new bullet and set them out to 1.150" and a few would hang up on the feed ramp on a gun that never malfunctioned before. Thus I found where OAL affects reliability, thus I shortened the OAL up.

Both my G32 and G33 have the newer barrels with the narrower feed ramp and the #2 followers and have had not malfunctions (other than my long OAL test reloads) Try some FMJ like Speer Lawman, S&B, Federal and etc to see if you have issues. The variation in OAL on the rounds you posted seems very large to me. I try to keep my reloads better than +- .003" variation from the targeted OAL.
Very true regarding gold dots. My Dept. Was starting to have problems with the gold dots hanging up on the feed ramp when we switched from sig to glock 31 gen4. Tested hst and not one problem. Switched to the hst and very happy. Excellent round in 357sig

Fellix369
10-09-2012, 09:05
They were 13 rounders.
I'm not not an expert by any means, but why do your 13 round mags have followers designed for 10 round mags?

hamster
10-09-2012, 10:18
I'm not not an expert by any means, but why do your 13 round mags have followers designed for 10 round mags?

I'll post a photo of the followers when I get some time later.

TxGlock9
10-09-2012, 11:36
Did the same happen with other rounds as well? What did you replace the G32 with?

With the Gen3 G32 I shot Winchester white box and WWB jhp, GA arms ammo, and Gold dot HP. They all jammed with the exception of the GD's but that's because I only shot about 10 rounds through it. That was enough for me to not want the G32 any longer.

On the other hand the G22 with 31 barrel did absolutely fine with GA arms ammo. Go figure.

I didn't replace the G32 with anything. I just got rid of it. I only shoot 9mm and 45acp now.

k9storm2003
10-10-2012, 13:24
I also have a Glock 32 Gen 4 that was manufactured in August 2012. My magazine followers are marked .357/3. They are 13 rd magazine. I also have been using Georgia Arms FMJ rounds without any problems.

Ben B
10-11-2012, 11:43
I'm going to try a different brand of ammo because as has been said, that is my #1 suspect. Probably their round nose stock still would have been fine, but with the GDHP, the out of spec just plain causes failures.

I will say, this is the worst experience I've ever had with any handgun/ammo combination and has shaken my confidence in the pistol even though logically I know it is most likely not at fault. I will have to shoot at least 300 rounds without a hiccup before I'd feel comfortable carrying it at this point. This experience just goes to prove how critical it is to test HP carry loads as well as practice loads... you just never know.

Now I just need to find 300 reasonably priced .357 sig rounds. :)
Underwood ammo. I use them for target and self defense rounds. Both have been flawless and powerful loads. The self defense rounds are new cases.

tacticalG23
10-11-2012, 17:55
I would suggest a Nub removal from the magazine if the mag has them. To check you just push down the follower and look at the steel walls under the feed lips inside the magazine. Should be triangular polymer nubs on both sides.
I had misfeeds originally with mine, read a thread a few months back on failures to feed, shaved those nubs off with a sharp blade, feeding flawlessly ever since. /runonsentence

Found a pic from a different thread. http://i51.tinypic.com/2a649he.jpg

hamster
10-13-2012, 12:57
I would suggest a Nub removal from the magazine if the mag has them. To check you just push down the follower and look at the steel walls under the feed lips inside the magazine. Should be triangular polymer nubs on both sides.
I had misfeeds originally with mine, read a thread a few months back on failures to feed, shaved those nubs off with a sharp blade, feeding flawlessly ever since. /runonsentence

Found a pic from a different thread. http://i51.tinypic.com/2a649he.jpg

Thanks. If the ammo doesn't work I will try the nubectomy.

voyager4520
10-13-2012, 13:16
You don't have to follow the specific instructions in that nub removal picture. You can shave them down any way you like, you can remove them entirely if you need to.

Giggity-Giggity
10-13-2012, 13:38
Change ammo.

dgbee456
10-14-2012, 23:33
let us know..

I bought a used G32 with a 2004 serial number.

It has that less rounded feed ramp and I only put 150 rounds through it and I did have a round seem to nose dive and Failure to Feed.

I was thinking it might be old mags from 2003 but they do have the 2 Follower.