A grand on a new. My first. AR. What to get? [Archive] - Glock Talk

PDA

View Full Version : A grand on a new. My first. AR. What to get?


jonny772
11-16-2012, 12:00
Well I have about a grand to get my first complete rifle and am looking for suggestions. I would be using it for plinking and home defense if needed. Looked at the stag model 1 and it seems like a great deal at 950. Thanks

Fwdftw
11-16-2012, 12:09
walmart colt 6920

bmoore
11-16-2012, 12:18
Colt 6920 or build a BCM. Get the most for your money.

Brian Brazier
11-16-2012, 12:22
Not trying to be rude, but you should really look through the already established "what should I buy threads". The last one is up to 9 or 10 pages of arguing about irrelevant crap, use google or your search engine of choice to research different brands, cause the only awnser you will get is Colt, Daniel Defense, LMT, and BCM are the only brands worthy of perchase, which is grossly untrue. I have no experiance with Stag, do your homework and look at what owners of them are saying. I have owned 2 Doublestar rifles, the one I have now is an M4 style, the other was a 20" A4, both have worked flawlessly, all the parts that should be staked are staked correctly, the fit and finish is excellent, goes bang everytime I pull the trigger, whats not to like.

P99er
11-16-2012, 12:31
colt 6920 or build a bcm. Get the most for your money.

+1...

P99er
11-16-2012, 12:35
You should be patient and save another $2k and buy a Noveske. It's the only weapon I would trust my life with. :rofl: :rofl:

LA_357SIG
11-16-2012, 13:22
I suggest reading the stickies on top of this forum, and make your own decision. Asking here will only get you suggestions based on little else than personal preference and brand loyalty.
http://www.glocktalk.com/forums/showpost.php?p=16903319&postcount=1
http://www.glocktalk.com/forums/showpost.php?p=17747770&postcount=1
ETA: and this http://www.m4carbine.net/showpost.php?p=75568&postcount=1

OR...

Just go to a few local gun shops and big name chain stores, look at a few models you are interested in, do some research online about the ones you like, and buy the one closest to your price range.

Sporaticus
11-16-2012, 18:24
I suggest reading the stickies on top of this forum, and make your own decision. Asking here will only get you suggestions based on little else than personal preference and brand loyalty.

OR...

Just go to a few local gun shops and big name chain stores, look at a few models you are interested in, do some research online about the ones you like, and buy the one closest to your price range.

The stickies in the forum are largely opinion skewed to the typical chart fan boy opinion.

They ARE a good place to start. But I don't think we would get much disagreement that if has have $1k he wants to spend on an AR, no training, no ammo, no optics. He definitely cannot go wrong with a BCM or Colt. Or I suppose even SW. I don't know what the fan boys think of SW, but I know folks who are happy with them.

But, if he wants gun, ammo and optics for that amount, that's different story.

Other links to consider:

http://www.m4carbine.net/showthread.php?t=7376

http://www.m4carbine.net/showthread.php?t=7355

jonny772
11-16-2012, 18:41
Thanks I have been searching the forums for ideas but nothing stag, or at least nothing that didn't turn into some other conversion:eek:

Sporaticus
11-16-2012, 18:45
Again, you can't go wrong with a BCM or Colt, and they are right at $1k. But there are other rifles that will suit your needs and leave you some cash for ammo, training, or optics.

vettely
11-16-2012, 21:27
I'm really digging my Sig M400 enhanced I got at Wally's for $917.

WoodenPlank
11-16-2012, 21:35
With your budget, I would look hard at a Colt. They can still be had online for right at $1,000. While it won't leave spare in your budget for extra mags and ammo, it's hard to beat a 6920. The mags and ammo can come over time.

mjkeat
11-16-2012, 22:17
OP, I would get the most value/quality as you can for your money. The biggest value is Daniel Defense though they run slightly more than your stated $1K budget. Colt and BCM would be great choices within that budget.

Be careful who you take advice from. Some here think barrels attach to lower receivers.

Cole125
11-16-2012, 22:44
Colt 6920, unquestionably the best AR15 for a grand.

Brian Brazier
11-16-2012, 22:57
Mjkeat, how can going well over a grand be a good value if thats what he s saying his budget is? For a plinking and home defense a S&W Sport, Doublestar M4 would be well under a grand, and be completley reliable. I am have no experiance with Stag, or Bushmaster, but there are plenty of people who own and love them as well. DPMS use to be the rifle everyone suggested people on a budget buy. How come everytime someone whats advise on a rifle, Daniel Defense, LMT, Colt, and BCM are the only viable options?

WoodenPlank
11-16-2012, 23:13
Mjkeat, how can going well over a grand be a good value if thats what he s saying his budget is? For a plinking and home defense a S&W Sport, Doublestar M4 would be well under a grand, and be completley reliable. I am have no experiance with Stag, or Bushmaster, but there are plenty of people who own and love them as well. DPMS use to be the rifle everyone suggested people on a budget buy. How come everytime someone whats advise on a rifle, Daniel Defense, LMT, Colt, and BCM are the only viable options?

Colts are available for under a grand if you shop around.

mjkeat
11-16-2012, 23:33
doubled...........

mjkeat
11-16-2012, 23:36
Mjkeat, how can going well over a grand be a good value if thats what he s saying his budget is? For a plinking and home defense a S&W Sport, Doublestar M4 would be well under a grand, and be completley reliable. I am have no experiance with Stag, or Bushmaster, but there are plenty of people who own and love them as well. DPMS use to be the rifle everyone suggested people on a budget buy. How come everytime someone whats advise on a rifle, Daniel Defense, LMT, Colt, and BCM are the only viable options?

I didn't recommend that he goes over his budget. I said DD is the best value. When you add up the parts that make up a DD, purchasing the complete AR is a good value.

People recommend those others because they reliably/consistently put out quality ARs. DPMS may have put out good stuff at one time or they may have not had much competition so they just appeared to be quality. The same could go w/ the companies that are considered GTG now. Who knows. Improvement is good. If DPMS changed things around and put out the best product, I'd own a DPMS.

Sporaticus
11-16-2012, 23:50
"Recommend". "Advice"? I think someone takes themselves too seriously. Especially when they use words like "rampid".

We are a bunch of nobody's on the internet having a discussion. Who is so full of themselves to think they are someone to "recommend" or give advice? All we can do, is offer our own perspective.

I guess it's different if you want to be the board guru and feel important. And that would explain always having to get the last word in, and rebut each and every differing opinion.

Advice? Not from this crowd.

Cole125
11-17-2012, 00:24
"Recommend". "Advice"? I think someone takes themselves too seriously. Especially when they use words like "rampid".

We are a bunch of nobody's on the internet having a discussion. Who is so full of themselves to think they are someone to "recommend" or give advice? All we can do, is offer our own perspective.

I guess it's different if you want to be the board guru and feel important. And that would explain always having to get the last word in, and rebut each and every differing opinion.

Advice? Not from this crowd.

And what is the point of your post? If you don't like internet forums, fine, but go away and stop trolling here.

Brian Brazier
11-17-2012, 00:38
I didn't recommend that he goes over his budget. I said DD is the best value. When you add up the parts that make up a DD, purchasing the complete AR is a good value.

People recommend those others because they reliably/consistently put out quality ARs. DPMS may have put out good stuff at one time or they may have not had much competition so they just appeared to be quality. The same could go w/ the companies that are considered GTG now. Who knows. Improvement is good. If DPMS changed things around and put out the best product, I'd own a DPMS.

I can understand why professionals buy DD, Noveske, or any of the other high end or custom AR's, they shoot most everyday and need a tool that will perform, that I get. On the other hand a shooter like the me who will shoot maybe 300rds a month (ballpark around what I shoot) I believe dosent need to spend that much for a rifle that will meet their needs, and be 100% reliable. If the buyer does their homework, knows what to look for in a quality rifle, there are some great values out there. Have you ever handled a DS rifle, or shot one?

GreenDrake
11-17-2012, 05:53
Cabelas has Bushmaster XM15 models for $649, best pricing I have seen in a while.

floorburn_21
11-17-2012, 06:18
I just posed the same question to myself about 3 months ago and ended up with a Colt 6920.

faawrenchbndr
11-17-2012, 06:41
......

Advice? Not from this crowd.

Another word you should look up & learn. :whistling:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Troll_(Internet)

faawrenchbndr
11-17-2012, 06:43
Well I have about a grand to get my first complete rifle and am looking for suggestions. I would be using it for plinking and home defense if needed. Looked at the stag model 1 and it seems like a great deal at 950. Thanks

Colt
BCM
Stag
Armalite
Windham
RRA

All great choices, within your budget! :supergrin:

mjkeat
11-17-2012, 09:58
I can understand why professionals buy DD, Noveske, or any of the other high end or custom AR's, they shoot most everyday and need a tool that will perform, that I get. On the other hand a shooter like the me who will shoot maybe 300rds a month (ballpark around what I shoot) I believe dosent need to spend that much for a rifle that will meet their needs, and be 100% reliable. If the buyer does their homework, knows what to look for in a quality rifle, there are some great values out there. Have you ever handled a DS rifle, or shot one?

A shooter doesn't need to spend large amounts to get a "high end" AR. That's why people recommend Colt, BCM, and DD.

I've done my homework and that's why I chose the ARs I did. Many others have done their homework as well and ended up at the same conclusion and thus recommend those quality companies. It's good advice.

I'm not saying that everyone needs a Noveske. If that was w/i his budget then it would be a great recommendation though. DD is slightly over his $1k budget as well. Now the thing to watch for is spending the same on a sub par AR when a quality one could have been had. A good example of that is DPMS's Warrior model. It runs in the same ballpark as the 6920. I think we all agree that getting the most for your money is good and would recommend it. Good advice?

Recommend, recommend, recommend.

Meow, do you know why I pulled you over? To make a recommendation.

K. Foster
11-17-2012, 10:37
The reason people recommend Colt, LMT, DD, etc, is that they use better parts, better assembly and QC than some other companies. Any company can put out a lemon but the better companies do not do so often. If you’re just going to shoot a couple thousand rounds a year, you’ll be fine with most brands. If you plan on high volume shooting, 6k to 10,000 rounds a year, You will see the difference between the upper and lower shelf brands. With 55g FMJ costing over $300 a case, it won’t take long for you to spend more on ammo that what your rifle and accessories cost so why not get the better gun? The buy once cry once philosophy has worked for me many times and never let me down.
Here’s a short explanation of some commonly discussed features, and why they are important.
Hope it helps.

Barrel Twist: The faster 1:7 twist will better stabilize the longer/heavier bullets above 69 grains. You can shoot 50 and 55 grain bullets just fine but your best accuracy will be with the heavier projectiles.
1:9 will generally provide better accuracy with 55 grain ammo than a 1:7 rifled barrel. As long as you stay between 50 and 69g your best accuracy will be determined more by bullet type then weight. In other words, match hollow points will give better results than FMJ.
1:8 obviously falls in the middle and although not as popular, is possibly the best all-around choice.
Barrel Steel: There are 2 basic grades of steel in common use. (Not counting stainless) 4150 is the preferred mil spec and is more resistant to heat than 4140. 4140 is often termed inferior, however it is in common use in the barrel making industry and for the casual shooter, you will likely never have a problem with it. IMO, a good reason to get a 4150 barrel is it is more likely to have come from a quality manufacturer. Keep in mind, most AR companies do not make their own barrels.
HPT: High Pressure Test. This involves firing a high pressure or "proof load" through the barrel and or bolt to see if it will take the stress.
MPI: Magnetic Particle Inspection. This is used to check for surface cracks in the part that may not be detectable by the naked eye, after the proof round has been fired. Just because you have HP/MPI parts does not mean they will never break, just that they are far less likely to. Also, HP/MPI is one more step in quality control and companies that perform or pay to have them performed are likely using all quality parts and doing everything else right, as well.
Staking: The gas key and the castle nut need to be staked to prevent them from vibrating loose. This is a very important step in the assembly process that some lower tier builders fail to accomplish. If you can see that metal from the gas key has been pushed up against both bolts, it’s done right.
“F” Front Sight Base: If you are buying a flat top carbine, you need an F (taller) FSB to be compatible with various aftermarket rear sights.
.223 & 5.56 chambers: These are not completely identical. Do some research. Most people recommend the slightly larger 5.56 as it allows both types of ammo to be used.
Chrome lined barrel: As a default recommendation, get a chrome lined barrel. The chrome lining will make extraction easier and make the barrel last longer and be less susceptible to corrosion.

Rooster Rugburn
11-17-2012, 13:23
If you are just starting the deciding process, your best bet will be to read up at M4Carbine.net, Arfcom, Chatterbox, and AR15 armory. There are a lot of folks at those boards whose expertise is at expert level. Those boards are dedicated to the AR15, and it's not just a sub-forum of another board.

M&P15T
11-17-2012, 13:33
Wanna buy mine?

I'm thinking of selling to get into a Daniel Defense.

http://i956.photobucket.com/albums/ae41/pugcra/DSCF0252.jpg