G19 or G30 ? [Archive] - Glock Talk

View Full Version : G19 or G30 ?


truxrme
11-23-2005, 03:38
Need some input on which model to get next, I keep looking at a 3rd gen G19 and see lots of advantages. However, the G30 has great fire power for a small package. I'm usually a 9mm type of guy and like the .45 ACP also. I always want to buy a pistol to CC., so with that being said please end this dillema! Oh, I currently have a G26 being sent to me.....
;Q

BikerRN
11-23-2005, 06:50
If you have a 26 I would go with the 19 because magazines for the 19 can be used in the 26.

I love my 19 and find I shoot better with the 9mm, and faster too, than I do with the 45. The 19 is a little slimmer too, which aids in concealability. Ammo for the 19 is cheaper, hence you get to practice more too. As far as the 45 being the ultimate manstopper, don't believe it. Both the 9mm and 45 acp are marginal as far as stopping ability and with today's modern defensive ammo the 9mm is right up there with the best 45 acp ammo.

I have and carry a Glock 36 or a 19. I don't feel undergunned with either one. Good luck and happy carrying.

Rusty Shackleford
11-23-2005, 06:51
If they both fit your hands well, you can't go wrong with either one.

The advantage to the G19 would be compatability with your G26. One holster will fit both, the mags from the G19 can be used in the G26, and most internal parts should be swappable.

BlackRifleFever
11-23-2005, 06:51
Those are two of the best glocks. You have to get them both.

truxrme
11-23-2005, 07:17
Originally posted by Rusty Shackleford
If they both fit your hands well, you can't go wrong with either one.

The advantage to the G19 would be compatability with your G26. One holster will fit both, the mags from the G19 can be used in the G26, and most internal parts should be swappable.

WoW, I did not know that the G19 will fit G26 holsters? Maybe I ought to get the G19 1st then the G30, it destined to happen anyway. Thanks for input...I also like the idea of the G19 having a light rail for your home defense in bedroom, and then being able to carry it during the day without it being unattended.

vafish
11-23-2005, 22:16
Originally posted by truxrme
WoW, I did not know that the G19 will fit G26 holsters?

As long as they are open bottom G26 holsters the G19 will fit in them. Some holsters are tapered or closed at the bottom and in those cased the G19 will not fit in the G26 models.

And the G26 will fit into any G19 holster, it just won't go all the way to the bottom.

oldbadge
11-26-2005, 11:34
I have a G26, a G23 with an additional Federal 9mm barrel, and the G30 with grip reduction shown. I love the G30 but if I could have only one pistol it would be the G23 with the Federal 9mm conversion barrel. The pistol is accurate with BOTH barrels.

d\guns\g30_1

oldbadge
11-26-2005, 11:38
sorry, here's the picture of the G30 with grip reduction.

Nosmik
11-26-2005, 18:18
I have tried those 3 main calibers (.45/40S&W/9mm) and ended up with the 19 and it is my favorite. Ammo is non expensive, great defense rounds and my wife can use it without problems. I think my next buy will be a 26 but so far the 19 takes the cake.
In less than a month, I have fired more than 500 rounds and the only problem was the followers and a specific brand of ammo (GD 147gr).

jlw_84
11-26-2005, 18:25
I've owned both, but I still have the 19.

Nothing wrong with the G30, other that it being a bit thick.

In conclusion, buy both. Just get the 19 first. ;)

Vincent Black
11-29-2005, 17:26
Originally posted by oldbadge
sorry, here's the picture of the G30 with grip reduction.

Niiice. How's the trigger reach comparied to the 19? Is it the same or close to it?

oldbadge
11-29-2005, 21:58
Seems very close to that of my G23. It is not pretty but it feels great. Why he did not do the back the same I do not know.

obxemt
11-29-2005, 22:54
Originally posted by jlw_84
I've owned both, but I still have the 19. Nothing wrong with the G30, other that it being a bit thick.

+1

cl147
11-30-2005, 01:27
Originally posted by obxemt
+1
+1 again.

buddyRoland
12-02-2005, 22:54
My G19 has always been my favorite Glock. When I got the G30 that all changed. The G30 is so accurate and smooth, it's a SUPER weapon IMO. I have so much fun with my G30 that I shoot all of my .45ACP ammo up first, before I even shoot my 9mm's, my favorite caliber. I am not saying I like my G30 better but just like it better for the moment. I am getting a P245 to keep my G30 company. Of course the G21 is on the horizon also. The G19 is still the ultimate Glock IMO. Light, slim compared to the .45ACPs, very accurate and cheap to shoot. Can't beat the overall package of the G19. Just glad I have both. Get either of these compacts.

http://www.regwebdesign.com/G19/g19left600.jpg
http://www.regwebdesign.com/G30/g30Left.jpg

JohnNC
12-03-2005, 09:49
I just got my G19 two weeks ago. I have been carrying it every day, all day, in a Blackhawk CQC Serpa holster, and it is so lightweight and comfortable that I forget it is there. I really like the holster, too. I wear it on my strong side hip, and it does print a little. However, the weather here is very mild, so I can wear a light jacket for concealment and look perfectly natural.

As far as shooting, the gun is a dream. Very easy to control, recoil management is not a problem at all. Groups very respectably at 15 meters, and I have no problem keeping them all in the K5 from 25 meters. I love this gun.

I bought it to replace my issued M9. It is a night and day difference. Love it.

Either way, you can't lose. Good luck with your search, and if in doubt BUY 'EM ALL!!!!!

JackC53
12-03-2005, 14:50
I've owned and shot a 21, 26 and 30. All are great guns. The 30 was built in Area 51;e but is a bit thick. A couple of weeks ago I bought a 19 and it is BY FAR the BEST handgun I have ever owned. And unlike a typical Glock, it even looks like what, IMHO, a gun is supposed to look like.

My 26 was a little small and my 30 was a little big but my 19 is just right. So, I named her "Goldi-Glocks". The 30 is a dream machine but is best for the range, the night table and cold weather (so you can cover it).

You will LOVE the 19. Then you can go buy the 30. Put a 33 round mag in and have some fun!! Since you will have a 19 and a 26 all you need to do is buy a KelTec Sub 9mm carbine that takes the same mags. You can get one NIB for around $250 and they are F-U-N!!

jAK-47http://i6.photobucket.com/albums/y234/jAK-47/Glock19.jpg

Scrappy
12-04-2005, 20:06
I have owned many Glocks. I have sold many Glocks.
The G30 I own is my favorite Glock and the one I can shoot most accurate as a big smile comes to my face.
For whatever reason I can not shoot the G19 very accurately, but the G26 I can shoot accurate. The trigger is not as good as the G30 even after swapping out parts same as the G30. Since you have the accurate G26 on the way ------- The G30 now has the rail too-------
I would tell you to get the BIG DAWG-----G30!;W

truxrme
12-10-2005, 13:06
Could not resist, next one will be G19!!!!

Scrappy
12-11-2005, 19:18
Wise choice;)
Enjoy:)

buddyRoland
12-13-2005, 22:07
Originally posted by truxrme
Could not resist, next one will be G19!!!!

That G30 is built just like you.:) You'll like the G19 also.

Sponsored Links:
Get Military Career
Thousands of Military Careers Choose One that's Right for You.
Navy - Official Site
Find Out What It Takes To Become a Sailor in the United States Navy.
Leupold Scopes - 30% Off Super Sale
Top Rated Leupold Spotting Scopes Site. Low Prices & Fast Shipping.
Gander Mountain-Official
Gear Up for Fields & Streams. Free Shipping on Orders Over $50.
Military? Earn Your Degree
Several Programs Available. Online, On-campus, or On base. Learn More.
Danner Duty Boots
Shop the Official Danner ® Site. Free Shipping and Free Returns.
MILITARY Rhinestone Pins
ARMY NAVY AIRFORCE USMC Rhinestone Pins & McCAIN PALIN.
Save on ACU Bags, Packs, Duffles
Buy ACU packs, military duffle bags, acu rucksacks. Huge selection.
Military Onesource - Military Info
Free info & assistance for all military personnel & their families.
Military History Training
Pursue a military history degree online. Learn how & enroll now.
Army Career
Special Benefits For Military Personnel. Army Career.
Blackhawk Holsters
High Quality Holsters for Firearms including 1911's, Glocks and More.
Military Training Classes Online
US Air Force personnel degree options. Get Univ of Phoenix info now.
Air Force Stuff
Support your Air Force hero! Buy Air Force clothing & gifts.
20% Back on Duty Boots
Up to 20% Back on Duty Boots. Sale Ends Soon. Supply is Limited.
Navy - Official Site
Find Out What It Takes To Become a Sailor in the United States Navy.
Cabelas Store
Save $20 on Express Shipping For Christmas delivery by 12/23.
Blackhawk Tactical
Great Airsoft Tactical Gear. Order Our Military Style Gear Now.
Buy Military Surplus
Low Prices on Military Surplus. 110% Satisfaction Guarantee.
Join the U.S. Army
Up to $73k for college. Explore the world, become a leader. Free info.
Dick's Sporting Goods
Find Top Quality Sporting Goods. Save 20% Off The Outlet.
Boots at 25-50% Off Retail Prices
Fast shipping, huge selection of Magnum®, Bates®, Thorogood®, Ridge® and Original SWAT® brand. Worn by hundreds of fire and police around the nation.
Duty Boots
Quality Bates footwear for military & other uniformed public services.
Tactical Holsters
Desantis’ holsters are the choice of the FBI, Secret Service, the U.S. Air Marshal Service and many agencies worldwide. Celebrating our 30th Anniversary.
Dewalt Steel Toe Boots
Rated ASTM Class 75 - the highest strength for impact and compression.
U.S. Air Force Academy
Find general information on the U.S. Air Force Academy.
Cheaper Than Dirt
Massive selection of the gear you want at Cheaper Than Dirt Prices.
Job Opportunities
Here's where you get the skills and drive you need to succeed.
Army Training
Official National Guard Site - Get Service & Benefit Info Now.
Military Online Store
Wide Selection of Kid Products Military Gear For Men, Women, Kids.
Sports Authority
Free Shipping & Guaranteed Delivery On Thousands of Great GIft Ideas.
Blackhawk Gear
Chicago Blackhawks Merchandise - Jerseys, T-Shirts, Hats, & More.
Ugg Boots for Kids
Hot Ugg Boots for Children. Great Selection, Easy Shopping.
Nikon, Leupold, Bushnell Optics
Free shipping on orders over $100.00 Nikon, Leupold Bushnell Products.
Military Armored Vehicle
Protect Yourself And Your Family As Down Economies Give Rise To Theft.