City's New Gun Control Laws are Unconstitutional, Says Phila. DA [Archive] - Glock Talk


View Full Version : City's New Gun Control Laws are Unconstitutional, Says Phila. DA

04-15-2008, 20:44
City's New Gun Control Laws are Unconstitutional, Says Phila. DA

by KYW's Tony Hanson and Mike Dunn

Philadelphia DA Lynne Abraham says the city's newly enacted gun control laws are unenforceable.

At a hearing on Tuesday before City Council, Abraham (above) said that in her opinion the laws passed last week (see related stories) are illegal and will be challenged as soon as the first person is charged under the new statutes.

And, she added, she thinks any defendant bringing a court challenge to the new laws would be successful.

The new laws include a requirement to report lost or stolen guns, and a one-per-person-per month limit on gun purchases.

Abraham agrees with state lawmakers that state law pre-empts the city in such matters and prevents any city in Pennsylvania from passing any such laws on its own.

When asked point-blank by a city councilmember if her office would enforce the new city gun control laws, she replied, "Nope." She warned that if police began making arrests under the new laws, the city could face a wholesale wave of civil rights lawsuits in response.

In reaction to DA Abraham's remarks before City Council, Mayor Nutter (right) said he hopes to discuss the DA's position further with her, and he hopes that his law department can convince Abraham that the laws are defensible:

"Much more conversation (with the DA) needs to take place about this. I think that these are legitimate pieces of legislation."

And Nutter also hopes to convince Abraham that the legislation is needed:

"Clearly we need this kind of help and support, and I'm hopeful that the DA will be a partner with us."

04-15-2008, 23:00
City's New Gun Control Laws are Unconstitutional, Says Phila. DA

Mayor and Police Chief respond, "nah-uh!"

04-16-2008, 14:54
Abraham is going to retire soon. I'm sure that her replacement will be more.....well....."reasonable"....

05-05-2008, 07:48
Now that one of Philly's Finest was murdered by 3 bank robbing thugs with an "AK-47", expect to hear all the anti-gun politicians and "journalists" start yapping that Philly MUST be allowed to make its own gun laws.
Nevermind that the 3 murdering thugs weren't choir-boys. Check out their mug-shots.
Oh, and here's a big surprise:

Eric Floyd, 33, believed to have escaped from a halfway house in Reading, is also wanted on a homicide charge. Police said Floyd should not have had access to a gun

Wanna bet those aren't their college graduation photos?

But....but....but.....I'm sure that their family and "friends" will manage to get air-time on the local TV stations to tell you about how they are really "good guys" and were loving fathers to all of their kids (by different women), etc. etc.

R.I.P. Officer Sgt. Stephen Liczbinski. This city doesn't deserve men like you.

05-05-2008, 08:09
How's that "gun court" going in philly? Where criminals, even repeat offender and felons, who use guns to commit crimes get "anger management class".


05-05-2008, 08:49
Wasn't this here last week too? ;)