which caliber for competition [Archive] - Glock Talk

View Full Version : which caliber for competition


LasVegasCop
04-29-2008, 23:33
I currently shoot in a local group called CPAAN here in Las Vegas.
I use my 1911 currently but I want to buy a competition gun and make it a race gun.
I plan on expanding to other shooting competitions including GSSF so I want my competition gun to be a Glock.

Originally I planned on the 34 9mm but after talking to others maybe the 35 .40cal would be a better choice
I wish they had a .45 long slide Comp gun.

I am not worried about the price of ammo in this case.

How many here shoot competitions and what is your Glock of choice?

Duck of Death
04-30-2008, 10:35
I have 2 G34 race guns others like the G17. Stick with 9mm---reason, more in the mag.

LasVegasCop
04-30-2008, 12:04
I have 2 G34 race guns others like the G17. Stick with 9mm---reason, more in the mag.

Have you ever shot steel with the 9mm?
Does it knock over plated and pepper poppers like the .40 or in my case .45 do?
I think that is my main concern.
Almost everyone that shoots competition with the bigger calibers say that the 9mm wont knock em down as fast sometimes causing you to shoot twice at one target..

any comments on barrels and an optic?

WellArmedSheep
04-30-2008, 12:25
If you're thinking about IPSC/USPSA you might want to go with a larger caliber than 9mm, since you have to worry about major/minor power factors...for IDPA 9mm would be a good caliber since everything is scored the same within a division. I've never had a problem knocking down steel with my G17, but I've never shot a match or stage that was predominantly steel...only a few poppers and plates mixed in with a bunch of cardboard for some variety.

Duck of Death
04-30-2008, 13:55
A 9mm major will take steel down just like a 38 super, you get up to a PF of 165 the steel WILL go down.

LasVegasCop
05-01-2008, 08:09
hmmm.. ok.. I guess I have to learn a little more about the minor and majors first before I decide...

9x45
05-02-2008, 08:00
For IDPA and USPSA Production, 9mm, for USPSA Limited, 40S&W (download to a 125 pf for IDPA). Poppers are allways calibrated to 9mm, and you don't wait for them to fall.

LasVegasCop
05-02-2008, 08:14
ok... I see.. I dont want to get into reloading either.
If it comes down to that I will go to a .38 Super.
So that leaves me back at my original question 9 or 40..
I guess I need to read about all the different classes and see if I would feel to limited with the 9mm, or not...

Jim Watson
05-02-2008, 09:25
Agree with 9x45.
If you don't handload, get the 9mm.
It will get you into USPSA Production and IDPA Stock Service Pistol or Enhanced Service Pistol with no major-minor scoring disadvantage. Everything scores Minor in Production, and IDPA requires Major only in CDP which has to be a .45 ACP anyhow.
By IPSC/USPSA rules and IDPA policy you are entitled to have steel targets set so a 9mm will knock them down and will get a reshoot if you obviously "ring" one and it does not fall.

If you get heavily into it and want to shoot a different Division, well, we all need a good excuse to buy another gun.

LasVegasCop
05-02-2008, 11:38
ok. I have a 21c and a 1911 to shot .45. so I think the 9mm it will be..

I think, lol

Duck of Death
05-02-2008, 12:14
If you want to shoot open and don't reload the G34 is a poor choice. It can be used in open but can't make major unless reloaded. If it's shot minor it will be scored minor, this goes for Limited and Limited 10. If you want to use the G34 in Production it will be fine.

MannyA
05-02-2008, 18:26
Get the G35, you can always get a KKM 40 to 9 conversion which works great. You can also get a 357 sig barrel and have a 3 caliber gun

LasVegasCop
05-02-2008, 19:48
why,oh why did I post this question.. :wow:

i think I will just get both then,, lol..

But Manny has a good option... Get the 35 and the KKM conversion.. hmmmmm

Jim Watson
05-02-2008, 20:35
USPSA Production does not allow caliber conversions, IDPA does not recognize them in any Division. Local club shoots seldom care or even notice, but if you wanted to enter a sizeable match, you would have to shoot the gun in its original caliber.

ede
05-03-2008, 05:53
for GSSF the 9mm might give you a edge in shooting less recoiling loads than the 40. for USPSA or any other game where PF is a factor the .40 would be the way to go. you can't make major with the 9mm except in open class.

LasVegasCop
05-03-2008, 09:28
USPSA Production does not allow caliber conversions, IDPA does not recognize them in any Division. Local club shoots seldom care or even notice, but if you wanted to enter a sizeable match, you would have to shoot the gun in its original caliber.

ok.. well I guess I just need to figure out what I want to do using factory ammo, no reloads.

Duck of Death
05-03-2008, 12:27
Unless I shoot my G34 Open Gun in USPSA I shoot a G26 or G17 in IDPA/SSP and USPSA/PRODUCTION usning 115 gr WWB purchased at Wal Mart. The G35 will give you more options but it will be hard to compete against a G34 in SSP/PRODUCTION unless you reload. In Limited 10 you'll be fine but in Limited you'll be round limited when shooting against the S_I guns.

I'd get the G34/G17 the ammo is cheaper and shoot SSP/PRODUCTION.

Sponsored Links:
Military Surplus Clothing
Cabela's Sale: Get $20 off Any $100 Order. Shop Now: Offer ends 12/08.
Night Vision at Sears
Free Shipping on Select Orders. Don't Give a Gift, Grant a Wish.
Shooting Supplies
Buy Shooting Supplies at SHOP.COM. Thousands of Brands. Hundreds of Stores. The Convenience of OneCart ™.
Construction Equipment Case
Need a Case to hold all your Equipment Needs at Discount Prices?
Buy Night Vision Scopes
Up to 50% OFF & Free UPS Full Warranty, Auth. Dealer.
Seahorse: Gun Case
Protect all your sensitive items from moisture, dust and unwanted visitors. Our gun cases allow you to carry and store your firearms and accessories without worrying about rough handling.
Military Employment
Special Benefits For Military Personnel. Military Employment.
Get Top Notch Tactical Training
Our students improve significantly - you can go to the range forever or spend 4 days at our resort. Our purpose is YOUR competence. Find out more with 15 Free Gun Training Reports and a DVD.
Propper BDUs @ BDU.COM
Every Fabric, Color & Size Largest Selection of BDUs Online.
Gun Cases
Cabela's Sale: Get $20 off Any $100 Order. Shop Now: Offer ends 12/08.
Get Military Career
Thousands of Military Careers Choose One that's Right for You.
Reloading Equipment
Free Shipping from Select Stores this Holiday Season at SHOP.COM!
Discount Shooting Supplies
Quality hunting supplies. Rifle scopes, knives, scent, ammo & targets.
Emergency Vehicle LED Lights
The latest technology saves you money as it lasts for years. We have a wide selection of LED Lights to outfit any vehicle.
Buy Military Surplus
Low Prices on Military Surplus. 110% Satisfaction Guarantee.
[+] Desert Tactical [+]
BlackHawk Tactical gear at Low Prices! Save 10% on your First Order.
Find Shooting Accessories
ITC Cheekrests, Cheekpads and More Shooting and Hunting Accessories.
Yazmo Case Superstore
Free shipping on all cases makeup cases, briefcases, laptop cases, make up artist cases. Top quality. Gun Case.
Atn Night Vision
Cabela's Sale: Get $20 off Any $100 Order. Shop Now: Offer ends 12/08.
Military Tranisition Resumes
Transition fast and effectively with a powerful, content enriched and demilitarized federal or civilian resume. We make employers understand your value and place you above the competition.
Reloading Equipment
Cabela's Sale: Get $20 off Any $100 Order. Shop Now: Offer ends 12/08.
Get Storm Cases - Now
Get Storm Cases & Accessories! Biggest Inventory of Cases at….
Save up to 50%, Free Ship & Gift
Night Vision 1st - 4th Gen, Night Vision scopes, goggles, monoculars, binoculars and rifle scopes. Free shipping.
Be a SWAT Agent
Advance your career. Earn a degree in Criminal Justice 100% online.
Sharpertek Ultrasonic Gun Cleaner
Factory Direct Deals at 40% off! Purchase now and and save.
Cheap Night Vision
10,000+ Choices for the Outdoors. Deals On cheap night Vision.
Navy - Official Site
Find Out What It Takes To Become a Sailor in the United States Navy.
Reloading Presses, Case Preparation
Reloading press for Cowboy Action.
Get Top Notch Swat Training
Our students improve significantly - you can go to the range forever or spend 4 days at our resort. Our purpose is YOUR competence. Find out more with 15 Free Gun Training Reports and a DVD.
US Army Online Store
Wide Selection of us army item Great Deals On Army Products.
Military Correspondence Classes
100% Tuition Assistance For Active Military Personnel. Get Free Info.
U.S. Air Force Careers
Learn More About Our Enlistment, Officer & Healthcare Careers Today.
Army Navy Surplus
20,000+ Army Navy Surplus Products Shop, Compare and Save at Pronto.
Once Fired Brass Cheap
Cleaned, Polished and Inspected all at a price you can afford.
Soviet Military Surplus
Soviet Military Surplus inventory over 200,000 items surplus and factory new.
Night Vision - Night Surveillance
Starting at $32.95, medium & long range IR illuminators available.