I carry my G23 in a Raven Phantom. Can not say enough good things about it. Fast production. LEO discount, comfortable for all day carry.
I just ordered a mag carrier and the pancake wings. I like how it holds to my body, but i figured I would give the pancakes a try as well.
OWB is so much more comfortable in my opinion, and the Phantom is, for me, the best holster for OWB.
I would agree with you, but then we would both be wrong!