Wow... I´m a little surprised that the G19 is ahead in the poll. I personally voted for the G19, but my story with the g19 is not what you can call typical. Never fired one or seen one, knew little about guns and owned none but wanted a gun and asked a friend what gun to get, he told me a G19 and so I did without even trying it. that was a long time ago, now I know a little more about guns. My point is that I voted for the G19 because it was my first gun. I love it, still if I for some reason was forced to have only one gun the G19 will be the keeper, but still I would tend to think that the G17 would be on the G19 toes as favorite. Anyways Go 19... you rule!!!!
Colt Commander Mk-IV
Llama Minimax 9mm, Bersa Thunder 22 22LR